Bethpage NY Market Report

or Create your own market report

When making a buying or selling decision, it is critical that you stay informed. Understanding what homes in your neighborhood are selling for will not only give you some insight on how you should price a home for sale if you are selling, but will also help you structure an offer if you are planning on buying.

If you are thinking of selling, this market report can help you price your home appropriately for sale. If you are thinking of buying, this market report can prevent you from offering more than what the home may be worth. In either case, you should stay knowledgable by reviewing this report.

Below, you will find a list of the properties in Bethpage New York that are currently for sale, currently under contract, and have sold within the past year. If you want to automatically be updated with the latest sales in the neighborhood monthly, please click on "Sign up for monthly reports" above. The latest market report will be sent to you on the first of every month.

You can also make a Custom Market Report for any development, neighborhood, city, or school district. You will love this tool to keep track of home prices and stay on top of your desired market.

Click here to find out more about Bethpage, New York or Nassau County, New York.

Thinking of selling your home? Contact Us today and let our team of talented local professional Realtors help you.

Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
2 Troscher Lane 4 3 1,423 $799,000 $561 2 days
42 Marbourne Road 4 3 2,300 $929,000 $403 2 days
54 S 1st Street 3 2 1,076 $749,900 $696 9 days
91 Evergreen Avenue N/A N/A N/A $699,999 Unknown 9 days
236 Bertram Place 3 2 1,662 $835,900 $502 27 days
81 Berkshire Road 3 2 1,190 $699,900 $588 11 days
3787 Windsor Drive 3 3 1,432 $719,999 $502 13 days
17 Wilson Lane 3 1 1,580 $792,000 $501 15 days
17 Sherwood Drive 4 2 1,658 $879,000 $530 17 days
40 Columbia Street 5 2 3,092 $1,099,000 $355 19 days
9 John Street 4 2 1,663 $899,000 $540 24 days
256 9th Street 5 2 1,190 $675,000 $567 26 days
132 Maple Avenue 3 1 864 $619,000 $716 27 days
58 Curtis Place 5 3 1,998 $725,000 $362 26 days
52 Concord Avenue 3 2 1,356 $999,999 $737 26 days
61 Cheshire Road 4 3 2,200 $999,000 $454 27 days
5 Robin Court 3 2 1,986 $875,000 $440 33 days
33 Sherwood Drive 4 2 1,928 $999,000 $518 36 days
16 Taft Avenue 5 3 2,604 $924,999 $355 44 days
260 8th Street 3 1 1,050 $599,990 $571 45 days
No address N/A N/A N/A $2,250,000 Unknown 46 days
623 stewart Avenue N/A N/A N/A $289,000 Unknown 47 days
52 Linden Avenue 5 4 3,800 $2,298,888 $604 59 days
12 Grant Avenue 3 1 1,100 $749,888 $681 62 days
125 S 5th Street 4 3 1,500 $779,000 $519 66 days
31 Cherry Avenue 3 2 1,910 $739,000 $386 72 days
208 N 3rd Street 3 2 1,007 $669,999 $665 75 days
16 Hunt Place 5 3 2,060 $929,000 $450 79 days
272 Broadway N/A N/A N/A $1,400,000 Unknown 90 days
79 Elizabeth Drive 5 3 2,250 $935,000 $415 89 days
139 maple Avenue 5 3 1,700 $1,199,990 $705 92 days
1234 Stewart Avenue N/A N/A N/A $2,475,000 Unknown 95 days
517 Corral Run 6 4 3,751 $1,349,888 $359 105 days
3850 Jean Avenue 4 2 1,275 $838,800 $657 108 days
43 Plainedge Drive 4 1 1,452 $679,000 $467 109 days
6 Stewart Avenue 4 4 2,500 $1,350,000 $540 171 days
21 Devon Road 5 4 2,870 $1,648,000 $574 138 days
690 Plainview Road 5 5 2,254 $1,900,000 $842 142 days
692 Plainview Road 5 2 2,254 $1,900,000 $842 142 days
110 Spruce Avenue Unit #Lot A 4 3 3,021 $1,465,000 $484 142 days
108 Spruce Avenue Unit #Lot B 4 3 3,021 $1,465,000 $484 142 days
5 Scherer Street 5 4 3,350 $1,860,000 $555 149 days
4203 Ludwig Lane 5 4 2,960 $1,549,000 $523 157 days
4195 Florence Road 4 2 1,868 $899,000 $481 152 days
65 Cheshire Road 4 3 1,450 $864,000 $595 188 days
12 Carson Street 5 3 1,600 $725,000 $453 190 days
Average: 4.1 2.6 1,980 $1,081,024 $541 73 days
Viewing 1 - 46 of 46
Viewing 1 - 46 of 46
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
600 Hicksville Road N/A N/A N/A $1,298,888 Unknown 8 days
83 S 3rd Street 3 1 1,050 $649,999 $619 44 days
32 Brenner Avenue 4 2 1,188 $699,000 $588 47 days
27 Park Lane 4 2 1,236 $724,000 $585 36 days
782 Stewart Avenue 5 2 1,688 $799,000 $473 13 days
11 Hoover Lane 3 1 901 $625,000 $693 15 days
18 Devon Road 3 2 916 $780,000 $851 45 days
634 Broadway 5 3 N/A $999,000 Unknown 11 days
24 Essen Place 4 2 N/A $779,990 Unknown 28 days
235 Hicksville Road Unit #2B 1 1 860 $299,504 $348 19 days
57 Caroline Street 4 2 2,046 $939,000 $458 44 days
19 Essex Road 3 2 1,242 $729,000 $586 14 days
42 Stewart Avenue 3 1 1,437 $625,000 $434 44 days
4185 Harriet Road 5 2 1,600 $895,000 $559 17 days
146 8th Street 3 2 1,025 $799,999 $780 10 days
4039 Hahn Avenue 3 2 1,854 $899,900 $485 53 days
210 N 5th Street 3 2 1,728 $849,999 $491 33 days
70 S 5th Street 3 1 920 $749,000 $814 41 days
131 S 5th Street 3 2 1,416 $749,000 $528 21 days
148 Harrison Avenue 6 2 1,964 $799,999 $407 24 days
173 12th Street 3 1 1,050 $674,777 $642 58 days
177 10th Street 3 2 987 $699,000 $708 70 days
39 Emma Street 2 1 735 $599,999 $816 60 days
2 Mozart Lane 2 1 1,039 $549,990 $529 6 days
7 Farmedge Road 3 2 1,152 $749,000 $650 33 days
53 Elizabeth Drive 3 2 1,978 $799,000 $403 51 days
4037 Jean Avenue 5 4 3,200 $1,699,000 $530 58 days
29 Edward Street 4 2 1,605 $775,000 $482 66 days
45 Concord Avenue 3 2 1,750 $829,000 $473 39 days
3591 Fiddler Lane 4 2 2,149 $679,000 $315 120 days
38 Hayden Drive 4 3 1,986 $1,050,000 $528 56 days
410-412 N Wantagh Avenue 4 3 N/A $1,580,000 Unknown 41 days
3962 Hahn Avenue 4 3 1,737 $799,000 $459 27 days
4 Patricia Court 5 3 2,069 $749,000 $362 14 days
72 Haypath Road 5 6 4,750 $2,599,999 $547 101 days
4236 Clarissa Road 4 2 1,496 $729,000 $487 102 days
27 Elizabeth Drive 4 2 1,588 $698,000 $439 74 days
4169 Iris Place 3 2 1,196 $659,000 $551 114 days
261 N 6th Street 3 2 1,606 $795,000 $495 153 days
4169 Iris Place N/A N/A N/A $659,000 Unknown 152 days
120 Brenner Avenue 6 4 1,754 $1,050,000 $598 230 days
3597 Martha Boulevard 5 2 2,000 $899,999 $449 26 days
57 Elizabeth Drive 4 2 1,901 $779,999 $410 33 days
8 Reading Lane 3 2 1,008 $550,000 $545 45 days
3643 Courtney Lane 3 2 1,325 $699,000 $527 34 days
22 Sherman Avenue 6 3 N/A $249,000 Unknown 3 days
149 Maple Avenue 3 2 864 $499,000 $577 20 days
Average: 3.7 2.1 1,560 $825,298 $542 50 days
Viewing 1 - 47 of 47
Viewing 1 - 47 of 47
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
12 E Millpage Drive 4 1 1,108 $615,000 $620,000 $559 47 days 10/30/26
316 Fern Place 3 1 1,190 $600,000 $625,000 $525 20 days 10/29/26
21 Morris Road 4 2 1,296 $699,000 $680,000 $524 30 days 10/29/26
14 Laurel Place 5 2 1,965 $838,000 $785,000 $399 44 days 10/29/26
21 Cypress Avenue 4 3 2,650 $1,449,000 $1,449,000 $546 30 days 10/28/26
78 Broadway 4 2 1,932 $799,000 $871,000 $450 20 days 10/22/26
23 Cambridge Avenue 4 3 2,416 $899,999 $930,000 $384 9 days 10/21/26
3636 Farmranch Road S 3 1 1,269 $649,000 $615,000 $484 27 days 10/9/26
35 Dennis Lane 5 4 2,756 $1,200,000 $1,230,000 $446 39 days 10/9/26
23 Martin Road S 3 2 1,079 $684,999 $670,000 $620 77 days 10/8/26
68 Maple Avenue 5 8 5,210 $2,749,999 $2,425,000 $465 89 days 10/2/26
315 Hicksville Road Unit #1 1 1 620 $309,999 $321,000 $517 23 days 10/1/26
19 Berkshire Road 4 3 1,946 $995,000 $1,050,000 $539 46 days 9/28/26
26 Essex Road 5 4 3,040 $1,399,999 $1,350,000 $444 165 days 9/28/26
2 East Court 4 2 1,896 $839,000 $905,000 $477 44 days 9/25/26
323 Hicksville Road Unit #4 1 1 755 $330,000 $355,000 $470 33 days 9/25/26
192 Sycamore Avenue 3 2 1,275 $699,900 $705,000 $552 22 days 9/24/26
337-9 Hicksville Road Unit #9 1 1 750 $325,000 $315,000 $420 14 days 9/24/26
63 Lincoln Boulevard 4 2 1,310 $725,000 $715,000 $545 13 days 9/23/26
5 Center Court 3 2 1,152 $649,000 $666,000 $578 14 days 9/22/26
4 West Court 4 2 1,625 $725,000 $770,000 $473 24 days 9/18/26
37 Seitz Drive 2 2 1,032 $699,000 $820,000 $794 14 days 9/18/26
15A Totten Street 4 2 2,244 $899,000 $890,000 $396 22 days 9/14/26
25 Laurel Place 5 3 1,697 $1,049,999 $993,000 $585 27 days 9/11/26
54 Cypress Avenue 5 3 1,413 $875,000 $858,000 $607 25 days 9/10/26
23 Kevin Lane 3 2 900 $674,999 $690,000 $766 36 days 9/9/26
71 Sycamore Avenue 4 1 1,119 $425,000 $575,000 $513 104 days 9/8/26
20 Carol Road 4 2 1,341 $799,999 $777,500 $579 25 days 9/3/26
440 Cole Place 4 2 1,275 $725,000 $760,000 $596 28 days 8/31/26
516 Lariat Lane 5 5 3,200 $1,479,000 $1,440,000 $450 107 days 8/31/26
98 Evergreen Avenue 3 2 1,168 $699,900 $750,000 $642 22 days 8/28/26
15 Russel Avenue 2 1 1,781 $779,999 $768,000 $431 29 days 8/28/26
29 Acme Avenue 3 3 1,519 $899,000 $955,000 $628 7 days 8/27/26
14 Concord Avenue 4 1 1,154 $599,995 $630,000 $545 13 days 8/26/26
3720 Farmedge Court 5 3 2,534 $999,999 $1,060,000 $418 17 days 8/26/26
512 Farmranch Road E 3 1 1,181 $659,000 $680,000 $575 9 days 8/24/26
14 McCord Place 3 2 1,862 $759,999 $759,999 $408 94 days 8/21/26
1050 Stewart Avenue 4 2 1,265 $699,999 $710,000 $561 59 days 8/20/26
4 Dennis Lane 3 2 1,404 $649,000 $660,000 $470 21 days 8/19/26
249 N 6th Street 5 3 2,401 $939,000 $939,000 $391 27 days 8/19/26
7 Cedar Avenue 5 4 3,200 $1,690,000 $1,690,000 $528 29 days 8/19/26
89 Sherman Avenue 4 2 1,414 $770,000 $772,100 $546 96 days 8/18/26
3836 Windsor Drive 3 2 1,410 $699,900 $721,500 $511 6 days 8/13/26
505 Lariat Lane 3 2 1,136 $759,990 $775,000 $682 43 days 8/12/26
6 Virginia Lane 2 1 948 $625,000 $640,000 $675 14 days 8/11/26
317 Herbert Place 4 1 1,726 $775,000 $750,000 $434 34 days 8/10/26
5 Totten Street 3 2 1,075 $689,000 $620,000 $576 55 days 8/10/26
136 Harrison Avenue 4 3 2,716 $949,999 $880,000 $324 59 days 8/10/26
70 Farmers Avenue 3 2 N/A $769,000 $735,000 Unknown 279 days 8/7/26
3 Cheshire Road 5 3 1,974 $929,000 $971,000 $491 14 days 8/6/26
Average: 3.7 2.3 1,733 $853,251 $861,191 $517 45 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 95
Viewing 1 - 50 of 95

How much is your home worth?

...get instant property value now!

Advanced Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.