Bay Shore NY Market Report

or Create your own market report

When making a buying or selling decision, it is critical that you stay informed. Understanding what homes in your neighborhood are selling for will not only give you some insight on how you should price a home for sale if you are selling, but will also help you structure an offer if you are planning on buying.

If you are thinking of selling, this market report can help you price your home appropriately for sale. If you are thinking of buying, this market report can prevent you from offering more than what the home may be worth. In either case, you should stay knowledgable by reviewing this report.

Below, you will find a list of the properties in Bay Shore New York that are currently for sale, currently under contract, and have sold within the past year. If you want to automatically be updated with the latest sales in the neighborhood monthly, please click on "Sign up for monthly reports" above. The latest market report will be sent to you on the first of every month.

You can also make a Custom Market Report for any development, neighborhood, city, or school district. You will love this tool to keep track of home prices and stay on top of your desired market.

Click here to find out more about Bay Shore, New York or Suffolk County, New York.

Thinking of selling your home? Contact Us today and let our team of talented local professional Realtors help you.

Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
933 Thompson Drive 3 3 1,693 $829,999 $490 6 days
2206 Union Boulevard 5 2 2,098 $739,000 $352 1 day
1560 Brightshore Boulevard 3 2 1,138 $649,999 $571 15 days
96 Chenango Drive 3 2 1,735 $649,000 $374 2 days
65 Mystic Circle 2 3 1,847 $650,000 $351 29 days
6 Hansen Street 5 2 1,488 $500,000 $336 5 days
300 Brook Avenue N/A N/A N/A $425,000 Unknown 5 days
1080 Ocean Avenue 4 2 2,048 $659,000 $321 6 days
26 Mystic Circle Unit #26 2 3 1,847 $699,000 $378 6 days
1641 E 3rd Avenue 5 4 2,577 $899,000 $348 6 days
182 New York Avenue 4 2 2,188 $665,000 $303 6 days
3 Hickory Place 3 2 1,986 $650,000 $327 7 days
249 Bay Shore Road 3 2 1,154 $515,000 $446 7 days
27 W Lakeland Street 4 2 2,174 $729,000 $335 8 days
92 Rhode Island Avenue 4 2 1,778 $699,999 $393 8 days
122 Corral Lane 3 3 2,077 $869,999 $418 16 days
100 Harrisburg Street 4 3 1,880 $649,000 $345 26 days
40 E Oakdale Street 4 2 1,380 $599,999 $434 20 days
109 New York Avenue 4 2 1,296 $679,000 $523 153 days
1431 Brooklyn Boulevard 4 2 1,466 $679,900 $463 11 days
1359 Manor Lane 3 2 1,385 $749,990 $541 12 days
9 Pleasant Lane 3 3 1,434 $669,000 $466 12 days
70 Massachusetts Avenue 6 5 2,551 $899,900 $352 45 days
418 Asharoken Boulevard 2 1 750 $499,990 $666 23 days
1 E Hemlock Drive Unit ##162 1 1 725 $220,000 $303 15 days
117 N Clinton Avenue 3 1 1,358 $500,000 $368 15 days
4 Sachs Street 3 1 880 $575,000 $653 16 days
31 Joyces Way 2 3 1,790 $849,000 $474 20 days
1340 Manor Lane 4 2 1,213 $679,000 $559 20 days
1142 Bay Shore Avenue 3 1 800 $489,000 $611 23 days
122 Jordan Street 4 2 1,258 $735,000 $584 20 days
218 Montana Avenue 6 3 2,052 $749,000 $365 22 days
1580 N Gardiner Drive 2 1 N/A $469,000 Unknown 33 days
1440 Lincoln Boulevard 3 1 1,464 $579,999 $396 21 days
1680 Pine Acres Boulevard 3 2 1,134 $525,000 $462 21 days
1443 Lombardy Boulevard 2 1 594 $540,000 $909 23 days
112 Monroe Avenue N/A N/A N/A $175,000 Unknown 26 days
1440 Lombardy Boulevard 4 2 1,120 $599,999 $535 27 days
1634 N Gardiner Drive 5 2 1,760 $749,999 $426 28 days
1288 Boston Avenue 4 3 1,944 $775,000 $398 33 days
1053 Ocean Avenue 3 2 1,501 $689,000 $459 35 days
19 Joan Road 4 5 2,840 $949,990 $334 35 days
202 Captains Way 2 2 1,796 $1,500,000 $835 58 days
1533 Agate Street 3 1 986 $560,000 $567 43 days
1333 Richland Boulevard 3 1 1,350 $629,999 $466 47 days
1828 Stein Drive 4 1 1,912 $684,999 $358 51 days
110 Queen Street 4 2 1,544 $599,999 $388 51 days
70 E Lakeland Street 3 1 800 $525,000 $656 51 days
1393 Gardiner Drive 4 2 1,695 $529,900 $312 54 days
12 Mallar Avenue 4 2 1,300 $649,000 $499 58 days
Average: 3.5 2.2 1,702 $774,272 $450 92 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 89
Viewing 1 - 50 of 89
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
1096 Manor Lane 3 2 1,143 $639,000 $559 10 days
1210 Hyman Avenue 6 5 3,205 $999,990 $312 21 days
7 Inca Drive 2 1 678 $429,999 $634 10 days
10 Boyd Avenue 4 3 3,066 $1,349,000 $439 27 days
194 Missouri Avenue 3 2 1,651 $769,000 $465 25 days
90 Rhode Island Avenue 4 2 1,398 $625,000 $447 19 days
1022 Fire Island Avenue 3 2 1,577 $649,000 $411 31 days
27 Brook Avenue 5 2 1,788 $699,000 $390 30 days
1632 N Thompson Drive 3 1 1,197 $499,999 $417 15 days
23 Anna Street 3 2 1,462 $625,000 $427 7 days
34 Cedar Ridge Lane 3 3 1,993 $749,000 $375 25 days
1614 N Gardiner Drive 3 1 1,191 $499,999 $419 35 days
5 Daniels Way 3 4 2,742 $850,000 $309 13 days
1032 Thompson Drive 3 2 1,000 $639,000 $639 6 days
64 Cedar Drive 3 2 1,874 $679,900 $362 25 days
28 Hemlock Lane 4 3 2,371 $825,000 $347 20 days
1015 Ocean Avenue 3 2 1,697 $649,000 $382 20 days
19 Westside Avenue 4 3 1,557 $599,999 $385 20 days
1327 Brooklyn Boulevard 3 3 2,184 $640,000 $293 28 days
40 Muncey Road 5 4 2,550 $899,999 $352 29 days
9 Sylvan Street 4 2 1,104 $650,000 $588 8 days
332 Delaware Avenue 3 1 1,263 $599,999 $475 10 days
1372 Pine Drive 5 2 1,734 $700,000 $403 22 days
1084 Hyman Avenue 3 2 1,220 $649,000 $531 22 days
1080 Bay Shore Avenue 3 1 1,800 $649,999 $361 27 days
1333 Boston Avenue 3 3 1,596 $719,000 $450 9 days
928 Manor Lane 3 2 1,677 $799,995 $477 18 days
802 Nebraska Avenue 4 2 1,440 $679,000 $471 71 days
110 Penataquit Avenue 3 2 1,193 $575,000 $481 21 days
1426 Ackerson Boulevard 3 2 N/A $649,990 Unknown 39 days
939 Manor Lane 4 3 2,329 $879,000 $377 36 days
2 Hemlock Court 4 2 2,300 $799,999 $347 35 days
34 Stewart Street 3 2 1,111 $549,000 $494 27 days
1414 Illinois Avenue 6 4 3,204 $799,000 $249 8 days
119 N 1st Avenue 3 3 888 $589,990 $664 29 days
73 Danbury Street 4 3 2,241 $749,000 $334 60 days
1456 Peters Boulevard 3 2 1,379 $499,999 $362 5 days
175 Candlewood Road 7 2 2,110 $725,000 $343 49 days
551 Spur Drive N 6 2 2,030 $599,999 $295 11 days
125 Missouri Avenue 5 3 1,642 $749,000 $456 65 days
1374 Saxon Avenue 4 2 1,658 $729,000 $439 38 days
1431 Lombardy Boulevard 3 2 1,338 $539,999 $403 25 days
1413 Peters Boulevard 3 2 1,458 $649,000 $445 44 days
1 Daniels Way 3 4 2,395 $699,999 $292 23 days
33 W Lakeland Street 3 2 1,639 $649,000 $395 29 days
1616 Baldwin Boulevard 3 1 800 $549,990 $687 36 days
1391 N Windsor Avenue 5 3 2,004 $749,000 $373 14 days
229 New York Avenue 5 2 2,118 $749,998 $354 32 days
1084 Joselson Avenue 3 1 848 $551,000 $649 15 days
188 Geneva Street 5 4 2,975 $835,000 $280 13 days
Average: 3.7 2.3 1,695 $656,348 $421 45 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 87
Viewing 1 - 50 of 87
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
1321 Thompson Drive 4 2 1,716 $699,999 $725,000 $422 17 days 7/28/26
130 Cedar Drive 5 2 2,160 $865,000 $870,000 $402 20 days 7/27/26
1707 N Gardiner Drive 4 3 1,658 $709,999 $790,000 $476 20 days 7/24/26
1026 Howells Road 3 2 1,422 $599,000 $651,000 $457 23 days 7/24/26
52 Mississippi Avenue 4 2 1,705 $598,999 $682,000 $400 76 days 7/23/26
5 Diane Place 4 2 2,015 $649,999 $670,000 $332 30 days 7/22/26
44 Redmond Avenue 2 1 900 $479,000 $480,000 $533 20 days 7/21/26
57 2nd Avenue 5 2 1,430 $625,000 $575,000 $402 102 days 7/21/26
344 Atlantic Avenue 3 2 1,250 $569,000 $610,000 $488 18 days 7/20/26
41 Princeton Street 4 2 1,410 $539,990 $515,000 $365 53 days 7/20/26
25 Shore Lane 5 4 2,785 $999,000 $999,000 $358 281 days 7/20/26
1 E Hemlock Drive Unit #Apt # 160 1 1 700 $205,000 $205,000 $292 24 days 7/15/26
1405 Ohio Avenue 4 2 2,100 $775,000 $760,000 $361 103 days 7/15/26
1643 Pine Acres Boulevard 3 2 1,374 $535,000 $660,000 $480 20 days 7/13/26
36 Hemlock Lane 5 4 3,927 $850,000 $975,000 $248 8 days 7/10/26
8 Henry Place 2 1 814 $473,000 $495,000 $608 45 days 7/9/26
10 Elm Avenue 3 1 1,200 $159,000 $159,000 $132 91 days 7/9/26
15 18th Avenue 3 1 1,054 $499,000 $530,000 $502 30 days 7/7/26
33 Center Avenue 5 1 1,132 $549,999 $575,000 $507 16 days 7/6/26
1597 Brentwood Road 5 3 2,004 $559,900 $580,000 $289 57 days 7/6/26
42 Greenwood Road Unit #Bay Shore, NY 11706 4 2 1,808 $724,000 $770,000 $425 15 days 7/2/26
52 Admirals Drive E 2 2 1,751 $779,999 $825,000 $471 56 days 7/2/26
152 New Jersey Avenue 3 1 1,000 $479,990 $475,000 $475 37 days 7/2/26
1333 5th Avenue 2 1 624 $399,999 $435,000 $697 23 days 7/1/26
1521 Pine Acres Boulevard 3 3 1,661 $589,000 $630,000 $379 102 days 6/30/26
848 Hampshire Road 3 2 1,744 $848,803 $750,000 $430 18 days 6/29/26
28 S Montgomery Avenue 7 4 3,864 $1,699,999 $1,625,000 $420 176 days 6/29/26
282 Helm Lane 3 3 2,108 $899,999 $945,000 $448 41 days 6/26/26
1678 N Thompson Divide 3 1 800 $530,000 $520,000 $650 153 days 6/26/26
284 4th Avenue 4 3 N/A $549,000 $530,000 Unknown 294 days 6/26/26
39 West Lane 4 4 3,442 $1,499,900 $1,300,000 $377 10 days 6/25/26
1193 Brookdale Avenue 5 3 1,197 $747,000 $750,000 $626 75 days 6/25/26
1644 N Gardiner Drive 6 2 2,416 $579,999 $630,000 $260 18 days 6/24/26
183 Captains Way 3 3 2,204 $1,200,000 $1,050,000 $476 133 days 6/24/26
236 New York Avenue 3 2 1,406 $599,999 $585,000 $416 93 days 6/24/26
No address 3 1 960 $479,990 $475,000 $494 97 days 6/23/26
76 Harrisburg Street 3 2 1,176 $649,000 $650,000 $552 105 days 6/23/26
62 Mystic Circle 3 3 1,931 $645,000 $625,000 $323 25 days 6/22/26
15 Doral Lane 3 3 1,817 $599,900 $615,000 $338 19 days 6/19/26
20 Ackerson Street N/A N/A N/A $795,000 $750,000 Unknown 241 days 6/18/26
163 Boathouse Lane Lane Unit #163 3 3 2,542 $775,000 $952,000 $374 34 days 6/17/26
105 Newbrook Lane Unit #105 1 1 N/A $329,900 $320,000 Unknown 47 days 6/17/26
1663 N Thompson Drive 2 1 928 $450,000 $430,000 $463 39 days 6/17/26
7 Montgomery Lane 3 2 1,468 $1,195,000 $985,000 $670 26 days 6/15/26
1137 Nugent Avenue 3 1 1,156 $599,000 $575,000 $497 92 days 6/10/26
1408 Saint Louis Avenue 4 2 1,246 $649,000 $685,000 $549 18 days 6/9/26
260 New Hampshire Avenue 3 3 1,628 $599,999 $653,000 $401 21 days 6/5/26
1730 Heckscher Avenue 4 2 1,648 $659,000 $710,000 $430 12 days 6/5/26
60 New Hampshire Avenue 5 2 2,218 $689,999 $705,000 $317 137 days 6/4/26
14 Garden Court 3 1 1,346 $589,000 $599,000 $445 138 days 6/4/26
Average: 3.4 2.1 1,641 $657,418 $669,603 $431 66 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 81
Viewing 1 - 50 of 81
Advanced Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.