Central Islip NY Market Report

or Create your own market report

When making a buying or selling decision, it is critical that you stay informed. Understanding what homes in your neighborhood are selling for will not only give you some insight on how you should price a home for sale if you are selling, but will also help you structure an offer if you are planning on buying.

If you are thinking of selling, this market report can help you price your home appropriately for sale. If you are thinking of buying, this market report can prevent you from offering more than what the home may be worth. In either case, you should stay knowledgable by reviewing this report.

Below, you will find a list of the properties in Central Islip New York that are currently for sale, currently under contract, and have sold within the past year. If you want to automatically be updated with the latest sales in the neighborhood monthly, please click on "Sign up for monthly reports" above. The latest market report will be sent to you on the first of every month.

You can also make a Custom Market Report for any development, neighborhood, city, or school district. You will love this tool to keep track of home prices and stay on top of your desired market.

Click here to find out more about Central Islip, New York or Suffolk County, New York.

Thinking of selling your home? Contact Us today and let our team of talented local professional Realtors help you.

Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
51 E Cedar Street 4 2 1,008 $579,000 $574 2 days
51 Bridger Boulevard 4 2 1,380 $549,000 $397 2 days
199 Cone Avenue 3 2 1,658 $610,000 $367 3 days
25 William Street 4 3 1,460 $675,000 $462 15 days
495 Earle Street 4 3 1,087 $629,900 $579 6 days
48 Cocoanut Street 3 1 829 $299,999 $361 7 days
348 Medea Way 2 2 1,224 $479,999 $392 10 days
141 Feller Drive Unit #141 2 1 828 $430,000 $519 16 days
26 Beech Street 3 2 1,129 $499,000 $441 14 days
75 Gates Avenue 4 2 1,046 $659,999 $630 15 days
237 Dovecote Lane 4 3 1,783 $649,999 $364 15 days
38 Tamarack Street 4 3 1,452 $599,000 $412 16 days
149 Maya Circle 2 3 1,746 $579,990 $332 31 days
2 E Elm Street 5 3 1,352 $625,000 $462 21 days
41 Fig Street 5 2 1,932 $730,000 $377 24 days
46 Oakland Avenue 5 4 2,084 $699,500 $335 22 days
28 Brightside Avenue N/A N/A N/A $75,000 Unknown 27 days
1525 Building Q Finch Lane Unit #1525 2 2 1,225 $479,000 $391 29 days
79 Fig Street 5 3 1,700 $650,000 $382 30 days
316 Leaf Avenue 3 1 1,024 $455,000 $444 30 days
6 Beech Street 2 2 1,129 $499,999 $442 30 days
43 2nd Avenue 4 2 2,038 $599,000 $293 31 days
269 Irving Street N/A N/A N/A $275,000 Unknown 33 days
10 Miller Avenue 6 2 3,010 $749,000 $248 48 days
41-43 Broadlawn Drive 3 3 2,311 $649,000 $280 38 days
264 Atlantic Street 5 3 2,272 $649,099 $285 46 days
10 1st Avenue 5 2 1,770 $709,990 $401 48 days
9 Okane Street 6 3 2,014 $879,999 $436 48 days
100 Wheeler Road 4 2 800 $649,000 $811 51 days
34 Peach Street 2 2 1,955 $549,000 $280 57 days
57 Adams Road Unit #2D 3 1 1,025 $360,000 $351 63 days
14 Lurcott Lane 3 1 1,595 $590,000 $369 73 days
2 Date Street 10 4 3,368 $850,000 $252 73 days
257 Southlawn Avenue 3 3 1,610 $849,000 $527 85 days
960 Ferndale Boulevard 5 3 1,802 $659,000 $365 90 days
69 Commercial Boulevard 7 5 3,195 $949,000 $297 104 days
245 Acorn Avenue 5 2 3,208 $859,000 $267 112 days
30 Tamarack Street 3 1 1,070 $499,999 $467 129 days
160 Bark Avenue 4 2 1,518 $650,000 $428 132 days
457 Nostrand Avenue 3 1 1,365 $540,000 $395 160 days
41 Tamarack Street 4 2 800 $590,000 $737 179 days
56 ash Street 3 2 900 $519,000 $576 304 days
258 Medea Way 2 2 1,224 $525,000 $428 339 days
Average: 3.9 2.3 1,607 $595,429 $418 61 days
Viewing 1 - 43 of 43
Viewing 1 - 43 of 43
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
32 Cypress Street 3 1 846 $350,000 $413 4 days
39 Church Street 5 2 971 $575,000 $592 13 days
135 Clayton Street 2 2 1,428 $529,999 $371 17 days
24 E Cherry Street 3 1 957 $529,000 $552 26 days
23 Peters Boulevard 3 2 1,000 $585,000 $585 30 days
94 Broadlawn Drive 2 2 1,590 $499,900 $314 28 days
27 Naples Avenue 3 1 1,327 $545,000 $410 23 days
9 Shady Lane 2 3 1,469 $560,000 $381 2 days
180 Whitetail Lane 3 1 888 $549,999 $619 18 days
465 Saint Johns Street 4 4 1,587 $499,000 $314 7 days
36 Hickory Street 3 2 1,244 $549,990 $442 26 days
345 Earle Street 4 2 1,400 $559,000 $399 14 days
47 Bayonne Avenue 2 1 1,074 $399,000 $371 30 days
147 Branch Avenue 5 2 1,900 $539,900 $284 42 days
36 Naples Avenue 4 2 1,195 $500,000 $418 35 days
1 Summerfield Circle 3 3 2,164 $579,000 $267 15 days
2232 Finch Lane Unit #2232 2 2 1,313 $487,777 $371 50 days
2 Clubhouse Circle 2 2 1,400 $499,999 $357 36 days
1072 Connetquot Avenue 3 2 1,099 $669,000 $608 8 days
31 Feller Drive 2 1 1,028 $325,000 $316 23 days
845 Islip Avenue 5 4 3,000 $1,198,888 $399 51 days
1927 Finch Lane 2 2 1,210 $475,000 $392 63 days
81 Sprucewood Boulevard 2 3 1,432 $529,000 $369 23 days
10 Francisco Avenue 3 2 1,384 $599,000 $432 60 days
59 E Elm Street 3 3 1,785 $649,999 $364 31 days
32 Weatherby Lane Unit ##32 2 2 1,202 $498,999 $415 42 days
19 Milford Drive 4 3 2,046 $628,000 $306 38 days
140 Poplar Street 3 2 1,386 $629,000 $453 14 days
981 Connetquot Avenue 3 3 1,518 $699,999 $461 79 days
4 Beech Street 2 3 1,400 $548,000 $391 27 days
1151 Connetquot Avenue 2 1 868 $479,999 $552 34 days
34 E Beech Street 4 4 2,364 $699,999 $296 19 days
85 Applegate Drive 4 3 1,904 $589,999 $309 64 days
8 Brightside Avenue 5 2 2,064 $769,999 $373 50 days
46 E Maple Street 4 2 1,366 $549,990 $402 53 days
103 Gates Avenue 5 2 1,578 $600,000 $380 102 days
3 Francisco Avenue 3 3 1,405 $599,999 $427 11 days
1 Spruce Lane 2 3 2,164 $549,999 $254 32 days
147 Ashley Court 2 2 1,056 $524,500 $496 58 days
115 Weatherby Lane 2 2 1,056 $518,500 $491 61 days
20-22 Broadlawn Drive 3 3 2,311 $599,999 $259 14 days
83 Broadlawn Drive 2 3 1,407 $549,000 $390 94 days
25 Hazel Street 3 2 1,531 $614,999 $401 75 days
13 E Walnut Street 4 2 1,700 $599,000 $352 87 days
89 Sportsmen Street 5 3 1,870 $689,900 $368 88 days
67 Sheldon Street 5 3 2,745 $699,999 $255 46 days
10 Hickory Street 5 2 1,411 $625,100 $443 100 days
410 Elmore Street 6 3 2,400 $629,000 $262 32 days
1068 Connetquot Avenue 3 2 1,099 $699,999 $636 43 days
106 Northwood Boulevard 2 2 1,380 $480,000 $347 165 days
Average: 3.4 2.3 1,508 $563,474 $406 91 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 66
Viewing 1 - 50 of 66
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
56 Bayonne Avenue 3 2 2,194 $649,999 $670,000 $305 11 days 7/28/26
22 Walnut Street 3 4 1,384 $505,000 $540,000 $390 18 days 7/24/26
57 Maple Wing Boulevard 2 2 1,400 $529,990 $528,000 $377 9 days 7/21/26
1540 Ferndale Boulevard 5 3 1,736 $599,999 $605,000 $348 20 days 7/15/26
23 Pineview Boulevard 4 2 1,890 $649,000 $665,000 $351 39 days 7/13/26
5 Hunter Drive 2 2 1,056 $519,000 $530,000 $501 9 days 7/7/26
114 Feller Drive 2 1 828 $340,000 $359,040 $433 18 days 7/7/26
44 Oak Street 3 2 1,196 $509,000 $520,000 $434 54 days 6/30/26
3 Adams Road 4 3 1,755 $649,900 $660,000 $376 22 days 6/30/26
33 E Cherry Street 4 2 1,096 $599,000 $599,000 $546 28 days 6/30/26
59 Adams Road 2 1 747 $329,900 $331,500 $443 76 days 6/30/26
332 Half Mile Road 3 2 1,775 $585,999 $600,000 $338 36 days 6/29/26
53 Spruce Street 3 1 1,230 $499,999 $480,000 $390 56 days 6/29/26
10 Linda Lane 3 2 1,100 $584,999 $570,000 $518 51 days 6/26/26
54 Ash Street 5 2 1,197 $579,999 $608,000 $507 59 days 6/24/26
108 Maya Circle 2 2 1,224 $499,999 $510,000 $416 13 days 6/24/26
76 Commercial Boulevard 3 2 1,437 $599,999 $645,000 $448 7 days 6/23/26
61 Adams Road Unit #2C 2 1 723 $399,999 $395,000 $546 20 days 6/23/26
340 Half Mile Road 3 3 1,300 $690,000 $700,000 $538 27 days 6/22/26
307 Medea Way 4 3 2,116 $589,000 $589,000 $278 57 days 6/15/26
452 Nostrand Avenue 4 1 1,880 $610,000 $610,000 $324 38 days 6/5/26
49 Peters Boulevard 4 3 1,748 $499,999 $540,000 $308 39 days 6/4/26
71 Adams Road Unit ##E 2A 2 1 837 $339,950 $317,500 $379 35 days 6/4/26
22 Fairlawn Drive 2 3 1,407 $500,000 $536,000 $380 81 days 6/3/26
508 Nostrand Avenue 6 2 1,050 $695,000 $760,000 $723 22 days 6/3/26
22 E Halley Lane 3 1 1,125 $515,000 $510,000 $453 96 days 6/3/26
76 Woodland Avenue 5 2 2,193 $581,000 $490,000 $223 18 days 6/1/26
2 Cherry Street 5 3 1,644 $679,999 $695,000 $422 46 days 6/1/26
34 Peach Street 2 2 1,955 $199,000 $350,000 $179 14 days 6/1/26
96 Somerton Avenue 2 2 1,464 $499,999 $530,000 $362 18 days 5/29/26
39 2nd Place 5 2 1,673 $699,998 $750,000 $448 73 days 5/29/26
17 Cedar Street 3 1 924 $474,000 $470,000 $508 37 days 5/28/26
11 Hunter Drive 2 2 1,056 $518,500 $500,000 $473 39 days 5/28/26
321 Medea Way 4 3 1,896 $559,990 $610,000 $321 23 days 5/28/26
1043 Wilson Boulevard 6 2 2,192 $624,999 $625,000 $285 20 days 5/28/26
72 Cranberry Street 3 2 992 $599,900 $635,000 $640 44 days 5/28/26
288 Feller Drive 3 2 1,172 $399,990 $400,000 $341 83 days 5/28/26
138 Weatherby Lane Unit #138 2 2 1,464 $499,000 $494,000 $337 28 days 5/26/26
73 Olive Street 6 3 2,054 $689,000 $710,000 $345 18 days 5/26/26
123 Feller Drive 2 1 828 $320,000 $290,000 $350 102 days 5/26/26
27 Ash Street 4 2 1,487 $599,999 $600,000 $403 55 days 5/20/26
100 Hawthorne Avenue 2 1 900 $319,000 $350,000 $388 22 days 5/17/26
13 Dietz Street 4 2 1,098 $575,000 $570,000 $519 57 days 5/15/26
189 Whitetail Lane 3 2 888 $639,900 $640,000 $720 18 days 5/14/26
19 Dawn Crescent 3 1 912 $399,919 $450,000 $493 20 days 5/13/26
61 Wheeler Road 4 3 1,446 $629,999 $660,000 $456 155 days 5/13/26
13 Poplar Street 4 1 1,090 $525,000 $550,000 $504 77 days 5/11/26
156 Gibbs Road 4 1 1,347 $549,999 $565,000 $419 17 days 5/8/26
41 Brightside Avenue 5 3 1,645 $685,000 $726,100 $441 36 days 5/8/26
2 Vita Drive 3 2 1,544 $594,000 $620,000 $401 17 days 5/7/26
Average: 3.4 2.0 1,397 $544,368 $558,447 $420 41 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 54
Viewing 1 - 50 of 54
Advanced Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.