Shirley NY Market Report

or Create your own market report

When making a buying or selling decision, it is critical that you stay informed. Understanding what homes in your neighborhood are selling for will not only give you some insight on how you should price a home for sale if you are selling, but will also help you structure an offer if you are planning on buying.

If you are thinking of selling, this market report can help you price your home appropriately for sale. If you are thinking of buying, this market report can prevent you from offering more than what the home may be worth. In either case, you should stay knowledgable by reviewing this report.

Below, you will find a list of the properties in Shirley New York that are currently for sale, currently under contract, and have sold within the past year. If you want to automatically be updated with the latest sales in the neighborhood monthly, please click on "Sign up for monthly reports" above. The latest market report will be sent to you on the first of every month.

You can also make a Custom Market Report for any development, neighborhood, city, or school district. You will love this tool to keep track of home prices and stay on top of your desired market.

Click here to find out more about Shirley, New York or Suffolk County, New York.

Thinking of selling your home? Contact Us today and let our team of talented local professional Realtors help you.

Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
62 Grandview Drive 4 2 1,673 $760,000 $454 6 days
61 W End Avenue 3 1 1,320 $499,000 $378 0 days
565 Starlight Drive 3 2 1,440 $659,000 $457 4 days
38 Appel Drive E 5 3 1,940 $650,000 $335 5 days
65 Westminster Drive 3 2 1,438 $569,900 $396 6 days
152 Parkwood Drive 3 3 1,402 $475,000 $338 6 days
37 Seymour Drive N/A N/A N/A $169,900 Unknown 7 days
7 Edwards Drive 3 1 1,192 $424,999 $356 14 days
31 Westwood Drive 4 2 962 $549,900 $571 14 days
12 Deer Path 4 4 2,848 $919,000 $322 16 days
14 Tudor Road 4 2 2,129 $615,000 $288 16 days
269 Carleton Drive E 3 3 1,085 $539,000 $496 17 days
25 Heston Road 4 2 1,962 $589,990 $300 18 days
4 Golden Gate Lane 3 3 2,408 $589,000 $244 27 days
8 Windus Drive 5 4 2,341 $499,000 $213 18 days
66 Corbin Avenue 3 2 1,868 $474,000 $253 89 days
74 Alcolade Drive E 4 2 1,640 $565,000 $344 19 days
43 Margin Drive W 3 2 2,242 $627,500 $279 20 days
50 Propose Road 4 2 1,770 $499,000 $281 69 days
16 Ormond Place 4 2 1,848 $549,999 $297 20 days
7 Candido Avenue S 3 1 1,092 $499,999 $457 20 days
33 Greentree Court 2 2 1,557 $510,000 $327 20 days
75 Presford Drive 4 2 1,284 $574,900 $447 21 days
Trafalgar Drive N/A N/A N/A $155,000 Unknown 23 days
16 Adobe Drive 3 2 1,172 $565,000 $482 27 days
35 Corbin Avenue 3 2 1,792 $549,000 $306 47 days
5 The Green Unit #B 3 2 1,410 $580,000 $411 29 days
146 Moriches Middle Island Road 4 4 1,296 $649,000 $500 28 days
89 Rugby Drive 3 1 990 $450,000 $454 28 days
119 Chanel Drive E 3 2 1,305 $500,000 $383 28 days
89 Argyle Drive 3 2 1,372 $369,000 $268 33 days
438 Auborn Avenue 3 2 1,100 $475,000 $431 33 days
90 Grandview Drive 3 1 1,248 $610,000 $488 35 days
22 Cricket Court 2 2 1,500 $425,000 $283 33 days
106 Chanel Drive E 4 4 1,726 $699,000 $404 33 days
138 River Road 3 2 1,075 $619,999 $576 35 days
2 Amarr Drive 4 3 1,392 $600,000 $431 36 days
16 Brushwood Drive 4 1 1,118 $519,000 $464 40 days
52 Victory Avenue 8 6 4,680 $759,000 $162 41 days
N/C 15 Robinson Drive 3 2 2,000 $609,990 $304 39 days
88 Pinewood Drive 3 1 1,058 $435,000 $411 43 days
152 Grand Avenue 3 2 1,000 $599,999 $599 47 days
19 Cypress Lane 3 1 1,152 $479,999 $416 57 days
18 Merrick Road 3 1 1,794 $569,999 $317 59 days
VL Johns Neck Road N/A N/A N/A $190,000 Unknown 60 days
42 Revilo Avenue 3 4 3,144 $849,500 $270 62 days
72 Concord Road 3 2 1,120 $659,999 $589 62 days
508 Starlight Drive 6 4 2,400 $799,999 $333 66 days
158 William Floyd Parkway 3 3 1,104 $550,000 $498 78 days
46 Brushwood Drive 8 3 3,750 $850,000 $226 72 days
Average: 3.5 2.2 1,675 $665,091 $375 124 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 83
Viewing 1 - 50 of 83
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
258 Floyd Road 3 2 1,076 $499,990 $464 13 days
11 Wood Avenue 4 1 1,248 $425,000 $340 17 days
70 Brushwood Drive 2 1 781 $349,000 $446 17 days
10 Windsor Place 3 3 2,594 $469,950 $181 16 days
465 Helene Avenue 5 3 1,976 $689,000 $348 25 days
34 Pinetop Drive 4 2 1 $649,000 Unknown 24 days
19 Golden Gate Drive 3 2 1,698 $629,990 $371 22 days
119 Parkwood Drive 4 1 1,008 $425,000 $421 28 days
6 Malba Drive 2 2 1,010 $469,999 $465 22 days
65 Winston Drive 3 2 1,056 $550,000 $520 32 days
64 Arpage Drive E 3 2 768 $385,000 $501 14 days
423 Free State Drive 3 2 1,250 $549,996 $439 39 days
68 Alcolade Drive E 3 1 1,146 $300,000 $261 21 days
489 Rowlinson Drive 3 2 1,852 $549,000 $296 2 days
5 A Stuart Road 3 2 1,200 $625,000 $520 20 days
34 Windus Drive 4 1 988 $499,000 $505 30 days
37 Sunset Drive 3 3 2,218 $599,000 $270 14 days
86 Parkview Drive 3 1 988 $399,999 $404 22 days
12 Heston Road 6 3 1,476 $569,999 $386 14 days
480 Sleepy Hollow Drive 3 2 1,522 $610,000 $400 17 days
North Street N/A N/A N/A $220,000 Unknown 36 days
43 Grand Avenue 3 1 1,058 $469,000 $443 92 days
41 Grand Avenue 3 1 1,058 $469,000 $443 98 days
153 Parkwood Drive 3 2 1,944 $565,000 $290 15 days
69 Appel Drive E 4 2 1,898 $549,999 $289 23 days
411 Glen Drive 2 3 N/A $350,000 Unknown 8 days
147 Hounslow Road 3 2 1,056 $589,000 $557 8 days
21 Probst Drive 3 1 1,058 $485,000 $458 38 days
147 Baybright Drive E 3 2 1,560 $574,990 $368 54 days
38 Argyle Drive 2 1 N/A $439,990 Unknown 14 days
489 Carnation Drive 6 3 2,400 $499,990 $208 10 days
20 Essex Circle 3 4 N/A $589,990 Unknown 21 days
135 Margin Drive E 4 2 1,418 $425,000 $299 19 days
1 Heston Road 3 1 1,016 $474,999 $467 58 days
30 Park Avenue 4 3 2,335 $680,000 $291 53 days
49 Kingsland Avenue 4 3 2,481 $729,999 $294 56 days
332 Commack Road 3 1 855 $395,000 $461 44 days
46 Lafayette Drive 3 2 1,188 $499,999 $420 51 days
432 Puritan Drive 4 4 2,588 $725,000 $280 65 days
198 Concord Road 4 3 1,152 $599,999 $520 58 days
39 Pinetop Drive 4 4 2,414 $669,000 $277 78 days
8 Lama Drive 4 2 1,775 $524,999 $295 65 days
162 Parkwood Drive 3 2 896 $499,000 $556 44 days
522 Rowlinson Drive 5 3 2,500 $629,900 $251 11 days
345 Commack Road 3 2 1,440 $569,999 $395 15 days
25 Revilo Avenue 3 2 2,228 $314,900 $141 86 days
19 Probst Drive 3 2 1,210 $599,999 $495 6 days
159 Parkwood Drive 3 1 1,034 $524,000 $506 87 days
7 Hollywood Drive 3 1 989 $449,999 $455 75 days
44 Westminster Drive 3 3 2,509 $599,000 $238 77 days
Average: 3.4 2.1 1,553 $494,594 $9,631 67 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 85
Viewing 1 - 50 of 85
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
20 Beacon Street 4 1 1,487 $520,000 $530,000 $356 29 days 7/28/26
19 Appel Drive E 3 2 1,260 $529,000 $560,000 $444 19 days 7/27/26
67 Westminster Drive 3 1 1,050 $399,000 $455,000 $433 14 days 7/24/26
167 Robinwood Drive 3 3 1,100 $475,000 $504,700 $458 33 days 7/24/26
19 Kent Drive 2 1 900 $425,000 $425,000 $472 98 days 7/22/26
194 E Parkview Drive 3 3 1,428 $550,000 $600,000 $420 113 days 7/22/26
171 Hounslow Road 3 3 1,236 $589,000 $589,000 $476 29 days 7/21/26
82 Brushwood Drive 3 1 1,050 $399,999 $405,000 $385 80 days 7/21/26
33 Ranch Drive N/A N/A N/A $150,000 $170,000 Unknown 40 days 7/21/26
17 Hampton Road 8 2 2,400 $549,999 $550,000 $229 13 days 7/17/26
34 Greentree Court 2 2 1,357 $515,000 $505,000 $372 92 days 7/16/26
516 Neighborhood Road 3 2 1,500 $499,999 $520,000 $346 80 days 7/16/26
Abby Lane N/A N/A N/A $129,500 $125,000 Unknown 51 days 7/14/26
19 Carmen View Drive 5 4 4,066 $949,000 $950,000 $233 44 days 7/13/26
47 Grand Avenue 3 2 1,008 $479,990 $525,000 $520 20 days 7/9/26
2 Ridge Road 5 2 2,200 $649,999 $635,000 $288 29 days 7/9/26
426 Lucerne Avenue 4 3 1,890 $669,000 $720,000 $380 35 days 7/9/26
160 Hounslow Road 3 2 896 $499,000 $550,000 $613 10 days 7/8/26
94 Lakeside Court 2 2 1,360 $529,999 $515,000 $378 22 days 7/7/26
30 Lombardy Drive 3 2 1,285 $525,000 $530,000 $412 27 days 7/2/26
199 Concord Road 4 2 1,572 $489,000 $535,000 $340 14 days 7/1/26
43 Abby Lane 3 1 1,008 $529,990 $520,000 $515 38 days 7/1/26
189 Grand Avenue 3 1 1,052 $420,000 $419,000 $398 66 days 6/30/26
13 Laurel Lane 3 2 1,464 $595,000 $615,000 $420 23 days 6/29/26
490 William Floyd Parkway 4 2 1,550 $599,000 $600,000 $387 30 days 6/29/26
187 Carleton Drive E 5 2 1,956 $625,000 $620,000 $316 292 days 6/29/26
458 Lockwood Drive 4 2 1,610 $599,000 $585,000 $363 18 days 6/26/26
38 Manor Drive 3 1 1,074 $399,999 $450,000 $418 50 days 6/25/26
248 Revilo Avenue 3 2 1,157 $599,999 $622,000 $537 20 days 6/24/26
53 Hounslow Road 3 2 2,033 $399,999 $399,000 $196 45 days 6/24/26
45 Oak Avenue 3 3 1,288 $649,000 $665,000 $516 26 days 6/24/26
38 Lafayette Drive 3 2 1,241 $499,000 $513,000 $413 81 days 6/24/26
137 Baybright Drive E 3 1 825 $399,999 $425,000 $515 17 days 6/22/26
32 Flintlock Drive 3 1 1,200 $519,999 $545,000 $454 35 days 6/22/26
131 Forrest Avenue 3 4 2,000 $599,989 $670,000 $335 8 days 6/22/26
606 Birch Hollow Drive 4 2 1,917 $625,000 $648,000 $338 49 days 6/22/26
3 Windus Drive 4 2 1,238 $519,000 $565,000 $456 14 days 6/18/26
70 Breston Drive E 4 3 2,041 $599,000 $628,000 $307 55 days 6/17/26
37 Linden Lane 5 2 1,082 $650,000 $655,000 $605 9 days 6/16/26
15 Loughlin Drive 3 2 1,518 $575,000 $625,000 $411 39 days 6/16/26
39 Appel Drive E 3 2 1,950 $650,000 $665,000 $341 137 days 6/15/26
7 Tipton Drive W 3 2 1,808 $589,990 $620,000 $342 17 days 6/9/26
19 Flintlock Drive 3 2 1,196 $529,990 $557,500 $466 10 days 6/9/26
31 Stanley Drive 3 1 1,092 $439,999 $460,000 $421 20 days 6/5/26
567 Puritan Drive 5 2 1,887 $599,000 $657,000 $348 71 days 6/4/26
2 Brushwood Drive 4 2 1,268 $549,999 $560,000 $441 74 days 6/4/26
34 Pinelawn Avenue 3 3 2,277 $429,999 $445,000 $195 45 days 6/2/26
31 Roneck Court 3 2 1,400 $639,999 $655,000 $467 16 days 6/1/26
40 St George Drive 4 3 2,042 $659,000 $680,000 $333 177 days 6/1/26
55 Trafalgar Drive 3 1 885 $369,000 $300,000 $338 33 days 5/29/26
Average: 3.4 2.0 1,486 $519,201 $533,144 $394 61 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 79
Viewing 1 - 50 of 79
Advanced Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.