Bay Shore NY Market Report

or Create your own market report

When making a buying or selling decision, it is critical that you stay informed. Understanding what homes in your neighborhood are selling for will not only give you some insight on how you should price a home for sale if you are selling, but will also help you structure an offer if you are planning on buying.

If you are thinking of selling, this market report can help you price your home appropriately for sale. If you are thinking of buying, this market report can prevent you from offering more than what the home may be worth. In either case, you should stay knowledgable by reviewing this report.

Below, you will find a list of the properties in Bay Shore New York that are currently for sale, currently under contract, and have sold within the past year. If you want to automatically be updated with the latest sales in the neighborhood monthly, please click on "Sign up for monthly reports" above. The latest market report will be sent to you on the first of every month.

You can also make a Custom Market Report for any development, neighborhood, city, or school district. You will love this tool to keep track of home prices and stay on top of your desired market.

Click here to find out more about Bay Shore, New York or Suffolk County, New York.

Thinking of selling your home? Contact Us today and let our team of talented local professional Realtors help you.

Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
111 Newbrook Lane 1 1 875 $159,000 $181 0 days
1357 Pine Acres Boulevard 3 1 N/A $529,900 Unknown 0 days
1627 Gardiner Drive 4 2 N/A $529,000 Unknown 1 day
1156 3rd Avenue 2 1 N/A $279,990 Unknown 1 day
974 Spur S Drive 4 2 2,400 $529,999 $220 2 days
1242 Brookdale Avenue 3 2 1,056 $349,000 $330 2 days
1416 Saxon 4 3 N/A $799,000 Unknown 2 days
186 Missouri Ave 7 4 N/A $549,000 Unknown 2 days
42 Krause Street 3 1 N/A $339,000 Unknown 2 days
1257 Hyman Avenue 4 1 1,400 $449,888 $321 0 days
125 Ocean Avenue 3 2 N/A $649,000 Unknown 3 days
58 Mississippi Avenue 3 1 N/A $415,000 Unknown 3 days
1097 Namdac Avenue 3 2 N/A $479,000 Unknown 3 days
66 Redmond Avenue 3 2 N/A $399,900 Unknown 4 days
11 Lakemont Street 7 3 2,000 $555,000 $277 4 days
909 Manor Lane 7 4 6,042 $999,999 $165 4 days
3 A Hemlock Drive Unit #126 2 1 N/A $189,000 Unknown 5 days
24 Girard Avenue 2 2 1,592 $519,000 $326 5 days
36 Maple Avenue 4 4 N/A $849,000 Unknown 7 days
1426 Brentwood Road 5 2 N/A $399,000 Unknown 11 days
60 Brook Street 3 2 N/A $439,999 Unknown 11 days
981 Spur Drive 2 2 N/A $399,000 Unknown 14 days
10 Jensen Rd 4 1 N/A $419,999 Unknown 16 days
Bay Place N/A N/A N/A $269,000 Unknown 16 days
74 Farrington Avenue 5 4 N/A $549,000 Unknown 8 days
873 Manor Lane 7 6 4,700 $999,900 $212 18 days
261 3rd Avenue 3 3 1,092 $389,000 $356 172 days
1515 Emkay Street 4 2 N/A $299,000 Unknown 19 days
86 Greenwood Rd 4 3 N/A $399,999 Unknown 21 days
2206 Union Boulevard 4 2 2,098 $389,900 $185 24 days
217 Elm Drive 3 2 N/A $399,990 Unknown 26 days
1423 Brentwood Road 3 1 N/A $399,999 Unknown 30 days
866 Manor Lane 4 4 4,700 $889,000 $189 26 days
102 Park Avenue 4 2 N/A $425,000 Unknown 31 days
15 Bay Way Avenue 3 2 1,542 $550,000 $356 32 days
42 Frederick Avenue 5 3 N/A $439,000 Unknown 33 days
15 Lakeside Lane 3 3 N/A $682,000 Unknown 37 days
1830 Union Boulevard 3 1 N/A $339,990 Unknown 38 days
6 Belgrave 3 1 N/A $399,900 Unknown 39 days
12 Mallar Avenue 4 2 N/A $599,000 Unknown 45 days
100 Queen Street 6 6 3,800 $749,000 $197 46 days
115 King Street 3 2 1,110 $469,000 $422 47 days
18 Garner Lane 5 6 5,900 $2,175,000 $368 49 days
1178 3rd Avenue 2 1 750 $269,900 $359 52 days
4 Harrison Place N/A N/A N/A $99,999 Unknown 52 days
Sunrise/Perkal N/A N/A N/A $675,000 Unknown 64 days
193 Newbrook Lane Unit #25 1 1 N/A $169,999 Unknown 66 days
1699 5th Avenue N/A N/A N/A $180,000 Unknown 67 days
46 Garden City Street 6 2 2,706 $515,000 $190 73 days
Lot 5 Overlea Court N/A N/A N/A $3,995,000 Unknown 88 days
Average: 3.8 2.5 2,805 $753,513 $290 84 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 90
Viewing 1 - 50 of 90
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
12 Lakeland Street 5 4 N/A $499,999 $520,000 Unknown 8 days 2/26/21
1356 Gardiner Drive 4 2 N/A $499,999 $510,000 Unknown 4 days 2/26/21
76 Center Ave Avenue 5 2 N/A $350,000 $311,000 Unknown 5 days 2/26/21
1337 Richland Boulevard 5 2 N/A $319,900 $325,000 Unknown 10 days 2/25/21
1 Benjamin Street 4 4 2,066 $559,000 $555,000 $268 35 days 2/25/21
19 Dalton Road 3 2 1,488 $460,000 $455,000 $305 14 days 2/25/21
140 New Jersey Avenue 3 2 N/A $399,500 $411,250 Unknown 46 days 2/24/21
1586 Gardiner Drive 3 2 1,136 $239,500 $265,000 $233 27 days 2/23/21
1574 Baldwin Boulevard 4 3 1,544 $379,000 $395,000 $255 18 days 2/22/21
49 2nd Avenue 3 2 N/A $399,000 $405,000 Unknown 17 days 2/22/21
194 5th Avenue 3 1 1,208 $329,990 $350,000 $289 17 days 2/19/21
1504 Thompson Drive 3 1 N/A $360,000 $420,000 Unknown 11 days 2/19/21
7 Oklahoma Avenue 3 3 1,500 $435,000 $427,450 $284 35 days 2/19/21
604 Asharoken Boulevard 5 2 1,472 $469,000 $469,000 $318 27 days 2/18/21
1038 Joselson Avenue 3 2 1,764 $399,900 $415,000 $235 23 days 2/12/21
12 Auburn E Avenue 3 3 1,250 $499,000 $499,999 $399 12 days 2/12/21
28 Brookdale Drive 4 2 N/A $409,990 $440,000 Unknown 5 days 2/11/21
1246 Saxon Avenue 2 1 1,200 $349,900 $322,000 $268 33 days 2/11/21
12 Lawrence Avenue 5 3 N/A $635,000 $615,000 Unknown 117 days 2/11/21
36 Abbott Place 3 2 N/A $570,000 $570,000 Unknown 48 days 2/10/21
1111 Nugent Avenue 3 2 N/A $349,000 $405,000 Unknown 6 days 2/10/21
49 Maple Avenue 6 4 N/A $599,990 $595,000 Unknown 54 days 2/10/21
1331 Ackerson Boulevard 3 2 1,421 $409,000 $450,000 $316 6 days 2/9/21
852 Hampshire Road 6 3 N/A $729,000 $739,000 Unknown 20 days 2/9/21
6 Dalton Road 4 2 N/A $389,999 $400,000 Unknown 30 days 2/9/21
119 Park Avenue 3 1 N/A $307,000 $323,999 Unknown 175 days 2/9/21
1579 Manatuck Boulevard 5 2 2,500 $499,990 $440,000 $176 20 days 2/8/21
34 Lakeland Street 4 1 N/A $369,000 $415,000 Unknown 4 days 2/5/21
1212 Howells Road 3 1 1,200 $349,999 $380,000 $316 9 days 2/5/21
39-39A Bay Shore Avenue 5 3 N/A $499,900 $600,000 Unknown 30 days 2/5/21
6 Meadow Drive 4 1 N/A $365,000 $375,000 Unknown 3 days 2/5/21
5 John Street 3 2 N/A $475,000 $470,000 Unknown 40 days 2/5/21
1807 Heckscher Avenue 3 2 N/A $450,000 $450,000 Unknown 62 days 2/5/21
79 Bardolier Lane 3 2 2,070 $445,000 $465,000 $224 11 days 2/3/21
1606 Gardiner Drive 3 1 N/A $340,000 $340,000 Unknown 27 days 2/2/21
1332 N.Clinton Ave 4 3 N/A $429,000 $447,000 Unknown 13 days 2/2/21
1410 Brooklyn Boulevard 5 2 N/A $469,999 $469,999 Unknown 29 days 2/2/21
1129 Hyman Avenue 3 2 N/A $399,000 $410,000 Unknown 40 days 2/2/21
16A Joseph Street 3 1 1,343 $395,000 $397,000 $295 35 days 2/2/21
1612 Brentwood Road 3 2 1,400 $399,000 $392,000 $280 6 days 2/2/21
611 Asharoken Boulevard 4 4 N/A $534,901 $535,000 Unknown 9 days 1/29/21
1683 Central Boulevard 6 2 2,317 $299,999 $290,000 $125 28 days 1/29/21
38 Farrington Avenue 5 2 N/A $445,000 $440,000 Unknown 161 days 1/28/21
14 Perkal Street 5 3 N/A $439,990 $419,120 Unknown 45 days 1/28/21
1155 Hyman Avenue 2 2 N/A $425,000 $435,500 Unknown 26 days 1/28/21
920 Candlewood Road 6 3 N/A $432,000 $424,875 Unknown 37 days 1/28/21
1034 Martinstein Avenue 4 2 N/A $449,000 $445,000 Unknown 17 days 1/27/21
1545 Agate Street 3 1 N/A $379,000 $379,000 Unknown 52 days 1/27/21
1 Plume Court 3 2 N/A $299,900 $315,000 Unknown 8 days 1/26/21
1228 Fairbanks Avenue 3 2 N/A $359,000 $360,000 Unknown 28 days 1/26/21
Average: 3.6 2.3 2,280 $446,922 $448,580 $256 36 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 161
Viewing 1 - 50 of 161


The data relating to real estate for sale or lease on this web site comes in part from HGMLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Real Estate Company are marked with the HGMLS logo or an abbreviated logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker. The information appearing herein has not been verified by the Hudson Gateway Multiple Listing Service, Inc. or the Hudson Gateway Association of Realtors, Inc. or by any individual(s) who may be affiliated with said entities, all of whom hereby collectively and severally disclaim any and all responsibility for the accuracy of the information appearing at this web site, at any time or from time to time. All such information should be independently verified by the recipient of such data. This data is not warranted for any purpose. Copyright 2021 Hudson Gateway Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.