Middle Island NY Market Report

or Create your own market report

When making a buying or selling decision, it is critical that you stay informed. Understanding what homes in your neighborhood are selling for will not only give you some insight on how you should price a home for sale if you are selling, but will also help you structure an offer if you are planning on buying.

If you are thinking of selling, this market report can help you price your home appropriately for sale. If you are thinking of buying, this market report can prevent you from offering more than what the home may be worth. In either case, you should stay knowledgable by reviewing this report.

Below, you will find a list of the properties in Middle Island New York that are currently for sale, currently under contract, and have sold within the past year. If you want to automatically be updated with the latest sales in the neighborhood monthly, please click on "Sign up for monthly reports" above. The latest market report will be sent to you on the first of every month.

You can also make a Custom Market Report for any development, neighborhood, city, or school district. You will love this tool to keep track of home prices and stay on top of your desired market.

Click here to find out more about Middle Island, New York or Suffolk County, New York.

Thinking of selling your home? Contact Us today and let our team of talented local professional Realtors help you.

Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
26 Cedar Lane 4 3 2,080 $675,000 $324 2 days
140 Bailey Court Unit #140 1 1 700 $210,000 $300 3 days
1 Lake Drive 5 4 3,955 $849,950 $214 5 days
3 Fairway Drive 5 3 2,309 $620,000 $268 6 days
283 Lake Pointe Drive Unit #283 2 1 996 $274,000 $275 8 days
10 Artist Lake Boulevard 3 2 1,865 $629,900 $337 10 days
186 Lake Point Circle cir Unit #186 2 1 1,000 $266,990 $266 14 days
66 Kate Circle 3 4 2,396 $749,000 $312 12 days
63 Bailey Court Unit #63 1 1 750 $219,000 $292 26 days
7 Redbud 3 3 1,728 $685,000 $396 17 days
194 Haddon Hollow Court 3 2 1,156 $419,990 $363 17 days
106 Bailey Court Unit #106 1 1 700 $205,000 $292 28 days
23 Saddlebrook Court 3 2 1,581 $549,000 $347 18 days
29 Madison Circle 2 2 1,421 $688,000 $484 18 days
2 Ord Court 3 3 2,125 $429,900 $202 48 days
62 Baily Court Unit #62 1 2 775 $194,900 $251 19 days
95 W Bartlett Road 4 3 1,248 $499,000 $399 19 days
173 Fairview Circle 2 2 947 $314,990 $332 19 days
24 Half Mile Road 4 3 3,926 $620,000 $157 19 days
33 Perri Circle 3 3 2,322 $569,999 $245 21 days
133 Fieldstone Court 2 2 1,133 $424,997 $375 23 days
80 Fairview Circle 2 2 920 $314,999 $342 24 days
43 Artist Lake Drive 1 1 830 $235,000 $283 25 days
5 Heather Court 3 2 1,230 $725,000 $589 25 days
14 Sophia Drive 2 2 1,444 $495,000 $342 28 days
161 Fairview Circle 2 2 947 $314,990 $332 27 days
63 Madison Circle 2 2 1,504 $545,000 $362 27 days
94 Gauguin Court Unit #94 2 1 900 $274,000 $304 29 days
56 E Bartlett Road 3 2 2,426 $620,000 $255 33 days
735 Spring Lake Drive 2 2 1,440 $459,000 $318 33 days
11 Eric Drive 2 2 1,440 $429,000 $297 35 days
65 Eric Drive 2 2 1,436 $419,900 $292 37 days
196 Fairview Circle 2 2 947 $339,900 $358 39 days
8 Lavern Drive 2 2 1,716 $499,999 $291 40 days
1 Jennifer Lane 2 2 1,873 $519,000 $277 40 days
20 Kate Circle 3 4 2,396 $699,999 $292 41 days
41 Madison Circle 2 2 1,504 $535,000 $355 54 days
840 Birchwood Park Drive 3 3 1,870 $499,999 $267 54 days
840 Birchwood Park Drive 3 3 1,870 $499,999 $267 54 days
764 Birchwood Park Drive 2 2 1,436 $399,900 $278 46 days
33 Pine Cone Street 2 2 792 $500,000 $631 47 days
717 Spring Lake Drive 2 2 1,568 $449,990 $286 55 days
78 Artist Lake Drive 2 2 1,098 $310,000 $282 63 days
7 Sander Court 4 4 2,600 $959,000 $368 68 days
194 Artist Lake Drive Unit #194 1 1 836 $269,999 $322 66 days
69 Fairview Circle 2 2 1,086 $364,990 $336 68 days
24 Oakcrest Avenue 3 1 890 $489,000 $549 82 days
282 Fairview Circle 2 2 947 $355,000 $374 82 days
10 Casey Lane 2 2 1,670 $489,990 $293 94 days
5 Charley Lane 2 2 1,670 $575,000 $344 87 days
Average: 2.5 2.1 1,541 $498,100 $337 106 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 69
Viewing 1 - 50 of 69
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
207 Lake Pointe Circle Unit #207 2 1 860 $239,000 $277 9 days
100 Fairview Circle 2 2 947 $325,000 $343 16 days
3 Putter Lane 4 3 2,000 $675,000 $337 28 days
33 Fairview Circle 2 2 N/A $329,990 Unknown 21 days
617 Granny 3 2 1,500 $519,999 $346 25 days
147 Fairview Circle Unit #147 2 2 947 $299,890 $316 26 days
273 Fairview Circle 2 2 947 $299,000 $315 17 days
39 Creekside Drive 3 2 1,745 $649,000 $371 29 days
57 Wellington Road 4 2 2,400 $674,900 $281 28 days
203 Lake Pointe Circle Unit #203 2 1 860 $239,000 $277 46 days
31 Cedar Branch Street 3 2 1,320 $549,000 $415 33 days
4 Balmoral Court 3 2 1,131 $459,000 $405 18 days
874 Birchwood Park Drive 2 1 1,100 $389,900 $354 41 days
349 Artist Lake Drive 2 2 947 $299,000 $315 62 days
14 Cedar Grove Terrace 4 3 2,484 $479,000 $192 70 days
6 Amesworth Court 3 2 1,332 $500,000 $375 39 days
10 Turnpike Boulevard 4 3 2,139 $679,000 $317 20 days
5 Cedar Grove Terrace 3 2 1,444 $599,990 $415 20 days
159 Fairview Circle Unit #291U 2 2 947 $355,000 $374 45 days
244 Lake Pointe Circle Unit ##244 2 1 999 $269,000 $269 105 days
1 Robert Lane 2 2 1,670 $525,000 $314 77 days
190 Lake Pointe Circle Unit #190 2 1 930 $285,000 $306 77 days
15 Sophia Drive 4 3 2,322 $585,000 $251 50 days
178 Fairview Circle 2 2 947 $325,000 $343 86 days
16 Yaphank Middle Island Road 3 1 1,250 $630,000 $504 38 days
84 Kate Circle 2 2 1,716 $534,900 $311 88 days
16 Winterberry Drive 3 3 1,944 $655,000 $336 61 days
124 Fairview Circle 2 2 947 $285,000 $300 43 days
515 Picasso Way Unit #515 2 1 901 $329,000 $365 98 days
182 Fairview Circle 2 2 941 $285,000 $302 27 days
219 Artist Lake Drive 2 2 1,100 $329,990 $299 69 days
231 artist lake Drive 1 1 850 $249,990 $294 56 days
71 Crystal Rock Court 3 2 1,332 $445,000 $334 116 days
50 Gauguin Court Unit #50 2 1 900 $269,990 $299 147 days
14 Julia Circle Unit #14 4 3 2,322 $609,000 $262 143 days
6 Julia Circle Unit #6 3 3 2,600 $634,900 $244 160 days
271 Lake Pointe Circle Unit #271 2 1 889 $250,000 $281 165 days
13 N Swezeytown Road 4 3 2,000 $669,900 $334 71 days
113 CURRANS Road 5 3 2,500 $810,000 $324 321 days
Average: 2.7 2.0 1,423 $449,675 $324 66 days
Viewing 1 - 39 of 39
Viewing 1 - 39 of 39
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
528 Lake Court Unit #528 2 1 910 $269,000 $250,000 $274 51 days 10/30/26
200 Lake Pointe Circle Unit #200 2 1 930 $249,000 $239,000 $256 50 days 10/30/26
4 Shelley Court 3 2 1,248 $579,000 $610,000 $488 19 days 10/28/26
W Bartlett Road N/A N/A N/A $235,000 $145,000 Unknown 273 days 10/28/26
6 Hines Road 1 1 636 $475,000 $480,000 $754 29 days 10/26/26
728 Birchwood Park Drive 3 3 1,870 $449,900 $449,900 $240 25 days 10/22/26
18 Elkin Drive 3 2 1,708 $599,990 $615,000 $360 22 days 10/19/26
18 Fairview Circle Unit #18 2 2 1,102 $364,990 $355,000 $322 24 days 10/16/26
524 Picasso Way Unit #524 1 1 700 $239,000 $231,500 $330 92 days 10/16/26
82 Kate Circle 2 2 1,716 $479,990 $490,000 $285 50 days 10/15/26
112 Dorado Court S 4 3 2,289 $549,900 $583,000 $254 47 days 10/13/26
8 Hannah Lane 2 2 1,716 $499,000 $487,500 $284 85 days 10/8/26
130 Park Lane 6 2 2,100 $674,900 $634,000 $301 100 days 10/7/26
22 Deer Avenue 3 3 2,591 $649,990 $685,000 $264 28 days 10/6/26
223 Artist Lake Drive 1 1 836 $250,000 $250,000 $299 47 days 10/5/26
8 Swezey Lane 5 4 2,194 $549,999 $625,000 $284 23 days 9/30/26
279 Artist Lake Drive 1 1 836 $200,000 $175,000 $209 36 days 9/30/26
10 Amesworth Court 3 2 1,157 $409,999 $433,000 $374 28 days 9/25/26
99 Fairview Circle Unit #211U 2 2 947 $285,000 $298,000 $314 15 days 9/23/26
605 Lake Court Unit #605 2 2 967 $329,000 $360,000 $372 420 days 9/17/26
33 East Street 3 2 1,020 $599,000 $610,000 $598 39 days 9/15/26
206 Dorado Court N 4 3 2,253 $549,000 $554,000 $245 35 days 9/15/26
4 Redbud Court 4 4 1,920 $689,000 $720,000 $375 35 days 9/14/26
Swezeytown Road S N/A N/A N/A $298,000 $260,000 Unknown 13 days 9/11/26
86 Bailey Court Unit #86 1 1 775 $189,900 $189,900 $245 125 days 9/11/26
738 Birchwood Park Drive 3 3 1,870 $450,000 $430,000 $229 81 days 9/11/26
16 Bailey Court Unit #16 1 1 750 $205,000 $208,000 $277 30 days 9/9/26
201 Lake Pointe Circle Unit #201 2 1 1,000 $250,000 $280,000 $280 47 days 9/8/26
66 Bailey Court Unit #66 1 1 775 $219,990 $225,000 $290 58 days 9/3/26
235 Ivy Meadow Court 3 2 1,156 $399,000 $365,000 $315 62 days 9/3/26
21 Pine Cone Street 5 3 2,029 $648,000 $635,000 $312 35 days 9/1/26
21 Elkin Drive 3 1 1,686 $549,990 $610,000 $361 43 days 8/31/26
282 Artist Lake Drive 1 1 836 $240,000 $250,000 $299 22 days 8/28/26
62 W Bartlett Road 4 3 1,872 $600,000 $525,000 $280 37 days 8/28/26
31 Artist Lake Boulevard 4 3 2,598 $599,000 $635,000 $244 22 days 8/27/26
621 Spring Lake Drive 2 2 1,444 $449,000 $480,000 $332 20 days 8/25/26
134 Park Lane 3 2 1,412 $489,000 $580,000 $410 9 days 8/24/26
129 Bailey Court Unit #129 1 1 700 $192,500 $194,425 $277 65 days 8/20/26
5 Fox Road 3 3 2,204 $699,999 $665,000 $301 336 days 8/18/26
53 Madison Circle 4 3 2,322 $649,999 $650,000 $279 16 days 8/17/26
28 Artist Lake Boulevard 4 3 2,358 $625,000 $641,000 $271 15 days 8/14/26
10 Artist Lake Drive 1 1 836 $210,000 $200,000 $239 28 days 8/14/26
19 West Street 4 4 2,037 $769,990 $760,000 $373 14 days 8/13/26
856 Birchwood Park Drive 2 2 1,414 $445,000 $430,000 $304 15 days 8/13/26
97 Artist Lake Drive 1 1 836 $249,000 $243,000 $290 22 days 8/10/26
59 Eric Drive 2 2 1,334 $449,990 $445,000 $333 18 days 8/10/26
11 Winterberry Drive 3 2 1,424 $599,999 $632,000 $443 38 days 8/7/26
135 Fieldstone Court 3 1 1,332 $349,000 $349,000 $262 35 days 8/7/26
92 Gauguin Court Unit #92 2 1 900 $320,000 $317,500 $352 51 days 8/5/26
83 Gauguin Court Unit #83 1 1 800 $199,999 $199,999 $249 83 days 8/3/26
Average: 2.6 2.0 1,423 $430,460 $433,594 $319 58 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 50
Viewing 1 - 50 of 50

How much is your home worth?

...get instant property value now!

Advanced Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.