Shelter Island NY Market Report

or Create your own market report

When making a buying or selling decision, it is critical that you stay informed. Understanding what homes in your neighborhood are selling for will not only give you some insight on how you should price a home for sale if you are selling, but will also help you structure an offer if you are planning on buying.

If you are thinking of selling, this market report can help you price your home appropriately for sale. If you are thinking of buying, this market report can prevent you from offering more than what the home may be worth. In either case, you should stay knowledgable by reviewing this report.

Below, you will find a list of the properties in Shelter Island New York that are currently for sale, currently under contract, and have sold within the past year. If you want to automatically be updated with the latest sales in the neighborhood monthly, please click on "Sign up for monthly reports" above. The latest market report will be sent to you on the first of every month.

You can also make a Custom Market Report for any development, neighborhood, city, or school district. You will love this tool to keep track of home prices and stay on top of your desired market.

Click here to find out more about Shelter Island, New York or Suffolk County, New York.

Thinking of selling your home? Contact Us today and let our team of talented local professional Realtors help you.

Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
14B Heron Lane N/A N/A N/A $3,750,000 Unknown 1 day
11 Jaspa Road 2 2 1,464 $1,350,000 $922 1 day
9 Bay Shore Drive N/A N/A N/A $1,595,000 Unknown 10 days
169 N Ferry Road 4 6 3,500 $4,250,000 $1,214 33 days
64A N Midway Road 5 4 2,642 $2,199,000 $832 52 days
6 Great Circle Drive 5 7 5,535 $4,995,000 $902 52 days
6 Oxford Avenue 4 2 2,074 $1,495,000 $720 80 days
21 Tims Trail N/A N/A N/A $575,000 Unknown 87 days
5 Sea Gull Road 5 5 3,072 $3,795,000 $1,235 89 days
43 Gardiners Bay Drive 5 5 6,106 $3,625,000 $593 89 days
16 Bowditch Road 3 2 1,266 $999,999 $789 89 days
90 Peconic Avenue 5 4 3,325 $4,800,000 $1,443 110 days
2 Prospect Avenue 6 3 5,900 $2,700,000 $457 107 days
4 Irene Lane 4 3 2,600 $1,850,000 $711 113 days
11 Mimosa Place 3 3 1,564 $1,275,000 $815 116 days
5 Marc Street 4 4 2,777 $1,999,999 $720 136 days
11 Sunnyside Avenue 4 6 4,000 $5,500,000 $1,375 141 days
9 Locust Woods Drive 4 4 3,856 $3,499,000 $907 158 days
14 Freds Lane 6 4 3,413 $2,239,000 $656 165 days
12 Terry Dr. 5 5 4,200 $2,800,000 $666 169 days
8 Hilo Drive 4 6 3,985 $3,850,000 $966 208 days
141A N Ferry Road 4 7 5,500 $3,999,000 $727 315 days
100 S Ferry Road 6 8 5,622 $4,295,000 $763 481 days
Average: 4.4 4.5 3,620 $2,931,999 $871 122 days
Viewing 1 - 23 of 23
Viewing 1 - 23 of 23
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
26 S Menantic Road 4 4 1,702 $1,450,000 $1,460,000 $857 305 days 8/27/26
73 N Midway Road 4 3 2,296 $1,845,000 $1,600,000 $696 251 days 8/24/26
16 Shelterlands Path 3 3 1,950 $1,175,000 $1,140,000 $584 58 days 7/20/26
10 Strawberry Lane 3 2 1,340 $1,195,000 $999,000 $745 211 days 6/11/26
21 Thompson Road 2 2 1,504 $5,875,000 $5,700,000 $3,789 116 days 4/7/26
1 Gazon Road 4 3 2,618 $1,250,000 $1,180,000 $450 160 days 3/26/26
Average: 3.3 2.8 1,901 $2,131,666 $2,013,166 $1,187 183 days
Viewing 1 - 6 of 6
Viewing 1 - 6 of 6
Advanced Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.