West Islip NY Market Report

or Create your own market report

When making a buying or selling decision, it is critical that you stay informed. Understanding what homes in your neighborhood are selling for will not only give you some insight on how you should price a home for sale if you are selling, but will also help you structure an offer if you are planning on buying.

If you are thinking of selling, this market report can help you price your home appropriately for sale. If you are thinking of buying, this market report can prevent you from offering more than what the home may be worth. In either case, you should stay knowledgable by reviewing this report.

Below, you will find a list of the properties in West Islip New York that are currently for sale, currently under contract, and have sold within the past year. If you want to automatically be updated with the latest sales in the neighborhood monthly, please click on "Sign up for monthly reports" above. The latest market report will be sent to you on the first of every month.

You can also make a Custom Market Report for any development, neighborhood, city, or school district. You will love this tool to keep track of home prices and stay on top of your desired market.

Click here to find out more about West Islip, New York or Suffolk County, New York.

Thinking of selling your home? Contact Us today and let our team of talented local professional Realtors help you.

Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
302 McCall Avenue 2 1 733 $550,000 $750 0 days
332 Myrtle Avenue 3 2 1,134 $719,900 $634 0 days
23 Roy Avenue 3 1 1,204 $635,000 $527 15 days
616 Pat Drive 3 2 2,118 $799,000 $377 23 days
703 Peter Paul Drive 5 3 2,502 $999,999 $399 2 days
73 Cherokee Avenue 4 2 1,793 $699,000 $389 14 days
320 Aster Road 4 2 1,400 $699,000 $499 43 days
37 Gladstone Avenue 5 3 2,963 $1,190,000 $401 9 days
731 Muncey Road 4 1 1,368 $719,000 $525 15 days
694 Pease Lane 5 2 2,305 $825,000 $357 23 days
308 McCall Avenue 3 2 1,326 $649,999 $490 14 days
86 Edmore Lane N 7 4 3,638 $1,075,000 $295 93 days
91 Spruce Avenue 4 2 1,479 $699,000 $472 22 days
466 W 4th Street 3 2 1,080 $679,000 $628 29 days
727 Peter Paul Drive 4 2 2,088 $829,000 $397 31 days
2109 Orinoco Drive 3 1 1,002 $600,000 $598 49 days
57 Sutton Court 1 1 720 $445,000 $618 33 days
136 Udall Road 5 4 2,440 $988,000 $404 42 days
851 W Bay Drive 4 3 2,200 $1,599,000 $726 43 days
1133 Patricia Avenue 5 3 3,664 $865,000 $236 51 days
511 Devon Place 4 3 2,726 $1,599,900 $586 52 days
230 W Islip Road 7 5 5,700 $1,799,999 $315 58 days
257 Shadybrook Lane 4 3 4,122 $1,699,000 $412 58 days
381 W 3rd Street 8 3 3,020 $749,000 $248 62 days
No address 6 7 6,893 $5,998,000 $870 297 days
385 Garden Street 3 2 1,848 $749,000 $405 99 days
418 Myrtle Avenue 4 2 1,820 $675,000 $370 99 days
88 Pace Drive S 5 5 3,860 $1,499,000 $388 128 days
160 Sequams Lane W 5 4 2,768 $1,495,000 $540 134 days
136 Udall Road 5 4 2,440 $999,000 $409 135 days
201 Union Boulevard N/A N/A N/A $4,200,000 Unknown 148 days
238 W Islip Road 3 2 2,000 $1,850,000 $925 169 days
894 Bay 9th Street 3 2 1,515 $669,900 $442 175 days
Beach Street, Union Boulevard N/A N/A N/A $199,000 Unknown 497 days
No address N/A N/A N/A $95,000 Unknown 196 days
230 Sequams Lane Center 3 2 1,785 $999,999 $560 236 days
306 Clay Avenue 3 2 1,176 $649,999 $552 404 days
Average: 4.1 2.6 2,318 $1,140,316 $492 95 days
Viewing 1 - 37 of 37
Viewing 1 - 37 of 37
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
61 Gridley Street 3 1 1,433 $689,000 $480 10 days
808 Fire Island Avenue 2 2 1,356 $699,000 $515 9 days
391 Oakwood Avenue 4 2 1,885 $799,999 $424 17 days
704 Myrtle Avenue 2 1 672 $525,000 $781 8 days
22 Larkspur Drive 5 3 2,607 $899,999 $345 7 days
19 Clearwater Lane 4 3 3,400 $1,299,000 $382 23 days
125 Raleigh Lane 4 2 1,874 $689,000 $367 11 days
822 Milligan Lane 2 1 1,181 $624,999 $529 39 days
348 Kurzon Road 3 2 1,008 $600,000 $595 39 days
134 Paris Court 4 3 1,868 $789,999 $422 8 days
1621 Madison Avenue 3 2 1,613 $679,999 $421 9 days
859 Pine Avenue 4 4 3,381 $1,025,000 $303 15 days
240 Eaton Lane 4 3 2,700 $1,250,000 $462 24 days
561 Center Dyre Avenue 3 2 1,502 $648,888 $432 14 days
835 Pease Lane 3 2 2,342 $879,000 $375 23 days
201 Wampum Lane 4 4 2,294 $899,900 $392 35 days
6 Gerek Avenue 4 2 1,296 $699,999 $540 30 days
527 Milligan Lane 4 2 N/A $785,000 Unknown 18 days
523 Hellwig Lane 5 3 2,813 $689,000 $244 56 days
1296 Oak Avenue 3 2 1,666 $729,000 $437 44 days
1 S Country Common 3 3 1,641 $675,000 $411 21 days
126 Eaton Lane 4 2 2,208 $799,000 $361 42 days
7 Sexton Drive 4 5 4,924 $3,690,000 $749 140 days
860 Udall Road 5 2 1,773 $680,000 $383 10 days
18 E Bay Drive 4 2 1,801 $650,000 $360 50 days
64 Kobb Boulevard 4 2 1,454 $725,000 $498 44 days
106 Anchorage Drive 3 3 2,336 $1,449,000 $620 20 days
1957 Jackson Avenue 4 3 2,144 $899,000 $419 16 days
714 Tanglewood Road 3 2 1,673 $699,000 $417 6 days
14 Willoughby Place 5 2 1,200 $601,000 $500 180 days
10 Roy Avenue 4 3 2,345 $799,000 $340 87 days
47 Myson Street 4 3 2,467 $721,000 $292 17 days
80 Udalia Court 3 3 1,600 $679,000 $424 20 days
800 Montauk Highway N/A N/A N/A $1,500,000 Unknown 134 days
Average: 3.6 2.5 2,014 $896,111 $444 36 days
Viewing 1 - 34 of 34
Viewing 1 - 34 of 34
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
105 Sequams Lane E 6 4 2,922 $1,250,000 $1,250,000 $427 14 days 9/9/26
71 Paprocki Avenue 1 1 700 $499,999 $526,000 $751 29 days 9/9/26
56 Morris Avenue 3 2 N/A $699,999 $715,000 Unknown 26 days 9/8/26
77 Toomey Road 6 2 3,062 $850,000 $925,000 $302 21 days 9/8/26
113 Duffy Place 3 2 1,528 $699,999 $775,000 $507 19 days 9/4/26
857 Milligan Lane 4 2 1,417 $730,000 $750,000 $529 34 days 9/2/26
735 Muncey Road 4 2 1,760 $699,000 $720,000 $409 27 days 9/2/26
634 Myrtle Avenue 4 3 2,676 $875,000 $940,000 $351 16 days 9/2/26
149 Raleigh Lane 4 3 1,874 $850,000 $850,000 $453 26 days 8/31/26
128 Pace Drive S 4 4 2,987 $1,599,000 $1,599,000 $535 14 days 8/31/26
94 Babylon Avenue 3 2 1,874 $649,000 $691,500 $368 10 days 8/28/26
16 West Street 3 2 1,404 $849,999 $875,000 $623 16 days 8/27/26
152 Pace Drive S 5 4 3,754 $1,599,000 $1,390,000 $370 52 days 8/26/26
66 Davison Lane E 3 3 2,752 $1,495,000 $1,400,000 $508 140 days 8/26/26
164 W Islip Road 4 3 3,692 $1,549,000 $1,600,000 $433 33 days 8/25/26
76 Beatrice Avenue 3 2 1,285 $749,999 $800,000 $622 56 days 8/25/26
488 Everdell Avenue 4 4 2,800 $999,900 $1,200,000 $428 17 days 8/20/26
19 Roy Avenue 3 1 1,346 $649,000 $680,000 $505 24 days 8/17/26
654 Alwick Avenue 4 2 1,982 $749,900 $840,000 $423 5 days 8/17/26
86 Paris Court 5 2 1,698 $679,000 $700,000 $412 8 days 8/17/26
5 Butler Street 3 3 2,477 $799,999 $870,000 $351 20 days 8/14/26
40 Deforest Avenue 4 3 2,062 $748,000 $675,000 $327 58 days 8/11/26
10 Magoun Road 4 6 5,317 $2,999,000 $3,225,000 $606 16 days 8/7/26
159 Driftwood Drive 4 3 2,620 $1,199,999 $1,200,000 $458 18 days 8/6/26
305 Kimberly Place 4 3 2,490 $829,000 $829,000 $332 29 days 8/6/26
10 Carolee Court 5 3 2,593 $1,049,000 $1,250,000 $482 30 days 8/6/26
48 Davison Lane E 4 3 2,159 $1,649,999 $1,650,000 $764 30 days 8/6/26
185 W Islip Road 5 4 3,400 $1,999,900 $2,000,000 $588 30 days 8/3/26
44 Archie Place 4 3 2,190 $899,999 $951,000 $434 14 days 8/3/26
532 Rockaway Street 4 2 1,008 $649,000 $700,000 $694 25 days 7/31/26
1657 Fairfax Avenue 4 3 2,236 $799,000 $807,500 $361 10 days 7/31/26
535 Kime Avenue 3 3 1,584 $629,000 $740,000 $467 8 days 7/31/26
11 Harvest Lane 4 3 2,313 $799,000 $900,000 $389 18 days 7/31/26
1632 Fairfax Avenue 4 3 1,989 $699,000 $735,000 $369 15 days 7/30/26
630 Oak Neck Road 2 1 1,435 $574,999 $628,000 $437 33 days 7/30/26
40 Wagstaff Lane 3 3 1,980 $1,195,000 $1,210,000 $611 26 days 7/29/26
3 Roy Avenue 3 1 1,169 $650,000 $675,000 $577 12 days 7/29/26
40 Alden Avenue 4 2 1,368 $730,000 $750,000 $548 18 days 7/28/26
209 Center Bay Drive 3 2 1,674 $669,999 $720,000 $430 27 days 7/28/26
14 Michalis Court 5 4 4,536 $1,399,999 $1,500,000 $330 33 days 7/28/26
580 Center Briarwood Avenue 4 4 2,546 $799,999 $830,000 $326 29 days 7/28/26
418 Bay 6th Street 4 3 1,946 $839,000 $912,500 $468 14 days 7/27/26
227 W Islip Road 4 3 4,069 $1,749,000 $1,700,000 $417 20 days 7/27/26
3 True Harbour Way 5 3 3,600 $2,299,000 $2,500,000 $694 10 days 7/23/26
11 Dolphin Lane 4 3 3,061 $1,700,000 $1,725,000 $563 11 days 7/20/26
145 Raleigh Lane 4 2 1,874 $685,000 $735,000 $392 55 days 7/20/26
185 Willetts Lane 5 3 5,400 $3,899,000 $3,905,000 $723 36 days 7/20/26
414 Myrtle Avenue 3 2 1,384 $649,000 $700,000 $505 7 days 7/17/26
70 Boulevard Avenue 4 2 1,885 $739,000 $830,000 $440 15 days 7/17/26
604 Center Briarwood Avenue 5 2 1,660 $699,999 $775,000 $466 12 days 7/16/26
Average: 3.9 2.7 2,354 $1,092,260 $1,126,462 $480 29 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 67
Viewing 1 - 50 of 67
Advanced Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.