West Islip NY Market Report

or Create your own market report

When making a buying or selling decision, it is critical that you stay informed. Understanding what homes in your neighborhood are selling for will not only give you some insight on how you should price a home for sale if you are selling, but will also help you structure an offer if you are planning on buying.

If you are thinking of selling, this market report can help you price your home appropriately for sale. If you are thinking of buying, this market report can prevent you from offering more than what the home may be worth. In either case, you should stay knowledgable by reviewing this report.

Below, you will find a list of the properties in West Islip New York that are currently for sale, currently under contract, and have sold within the past year. If you want to automatically be updated with the latest sales in the neighborhood monthly, please click on "Sign up for monthly reports" above. The latest market report will be sent to you on the first of every month.

You can also make a Custom Market Report for any development, neighborhood, city, or school district. You will love this tool to keep track of home prices and stay on top of your desired market.

Click here to find out more about West Islip, New York or Suffolk County, New York.

Thinking of selling your home? Contact Us today and let our team of talented local professional Realtors help you.

Active Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
47 Myson Street 4 3 N/A $679,990 Unknown 0 days
507 Pease Lane 5 3 2,600 $699,000 $268 1 day
750 Tanglewood Road 4 2 1,563 $799,000 $511 6 days
692 Keith Lane 4 2 1,722 $595,000 $345 6 days
23 Beatrice Avenue 4 2 2,064 $679,316 $329 1 day
69 Jean Road 4 1 N/A $449,990 Unknown 10 days
121 Wampum Lane 5 4 6,000 $1,899,999 $316 9 days
244 Tahlulah Lane 9 10 N/A $2,788,800 Unknown 28 days
171 Secatogue W Lane 4 3 N/A $1,200,000 Unknown 41 days
620 Union Boulevard N/A N/A N/A $65,000 Unknown 49 days
615 Center Bay Drive 4 2 N/A $569,000 Unknown 59 days
718 Tanglewood Road 3 2 N/A $599,000 Unknown 71 days
230 Willetts Lane 3 1 1,688 $779,000 $461 74 days
23 Viking Drive 4 3 N/A $925,000 Unknown 66 days
51 Beatrice Avenue 6 6 N/A $1,150,000 Unknown 112 days
214 Tahlulah Lane 4 3 N/A $1,175,000 Unknown 112 days
226 Tahlulah Lane 5 3 N/A $879,000 Unknown 115 days
434 Sunrise Highway N/A N/A N/A $549,000 Unknown 122 days
40 Skookwams 4 4 N/A $1,225,000 Unknown 126 days
300 Oak Neck Lane 4 3 N/A $1,125,000 Unknown 125 days
10 Hawley Avenue N/A N/A N/A $939,000 Unknown 362 days
202 1st Street 4 3 N/A $500,000 Unknown 99 days
36 Arbour Street 5 3 N/A $550,000 Unknown 484 days
Average: 4.5 3.1 2,606 $905,221 $372 54 days
Viewing 1 - 23 of 23
Viewing 1 - 23 of 23
Properties Under Contract
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
12 Larry Lane 6 3 N/A $849,000 Unknown 0 days
248 Norma Avenue 3 1 N/A $515,000 Unknown 8 days
22 Christopher Court 5 3 N/A $749,000 Unknown 15 days
5 Mallard 4 3 N/A $733,950 Unknown 15 days
525 Everdell Avenue 4 3 N/A $649,999 Unknown 13 days
841 Bay Drive 4 3 2,572 $899,000 $349 43 days
34 Duck Lane 3 2 1,510 $649,990 $430 26 days
192 Sequams Lane 3 2 N/A $789,888 Unknown 12 days
161 Norma Avenue 3 2 1,356 $539,000 $397 15 days
91 Penny Street 3 3 3,095 $629,000 $203 14 days
789 Keith Lane 4 2 1,138 $429,000 $376 4 days
66 Gladstone Avenue 4 2 N/A $539,999 Unknown 70 days
111 Babylon Avenue 4 2 N/A $549,000 Unknown 21 days
84 Doncaster Avenue 4 3 N/A $619,900 Unknown 55 days
748 Pease Lane 3 2 1,600 $649,999 $406 7 days
107 Edmore N Lane 4 1 N/A $449,990 Unknown 53 days
550 Peter Paul Drive 4 3 1,700 $649,990 $382 41 days
15 Cutter Court 4 3 2,500 $799,999 $319 0 days
23 Roderick Road 4 3 N/A $800,000 Unknown 81 days
2000 Jackson Avenue 4 2 1,260 $489,500 $388 29 days
78 Boulevard Avenue 4 3 1,879 $599,950 $319 53 days
59 Dubois Road 3 2 N/A $525,000 Unknown 26 days
505 Bay 5th Street 4 4 N/A $799,000 Unknown 36 days
52 Beatrice Avenue 3 1 1,900 $499,000 $262 12 days
141 Raleigh Lane 4 3 N/A $599,900 Unknown 11 days
1304 Roosevelt 3 2 N/A $519,990 Unknown 26 days
732 Sandra Avenue 3 2 N/A $450,000 Unknown 13 days
15 North Street 4 2 N/A $629,000 Unknown 8 days
557 Peter Paul Drive 5 2 N/A $649,000 Unknown 65 days
6 Carolee Court 4 5 3,600 $1,295,000 $359 89 days
55 Islip Road 3 2 N/A $599,990 Unknown 15 days
510 Center Bay Drive 4 2 N/A $599,000 Unknown 29 days
818 Higbie Lane 5 4 2,700 $698,900 $258 21 days
66 Arbour Street 4 2 2,427 $699,999 $288 61 days
102 Tahlulah Lane 4 4 3,857 $1,725,000 $447 42 days
435 Garden Street 4 2 N/A $520,000 Unknown 89 days
40 Sequams Lane 3 2 N/A $840,000 Unknown 85 days
48 Pace S Drive 5 3 3,000 $815,000 $271 13 days
308 Higbie Lane 8 4 N/A $669,999 Unknown 29 days
4 Roman Lane 5 2 2,340 $674,500 $288 11 days
417 Myrtle Avenue 3 2 N/A $549,990 Unknown 19 days
401 Mccall Avenue 8 3 N/A $574,990 Unknown 69 days
4 Sherman Avenue 4 4 N/A $749,000 Unknown 433 days
38 Gerek 4 3 2,800 $849,990 $303 88 days
435 Montauk Highway Unit #435 N/A N/A N/A $795,000 Unknown 169 days
4 Shoal Drive 5 6 N/A $2,999,000 Unknown 92 days
2 Dolphin Lane 5 4 N/A $1,579,000 Unknown 195 days
316 Kimberly Place 5 4 N/A $649,888 Unknown 95 days
139 Wagstaff Lane 5 5 4,500 $1,300,000 $288 27 days
700 Pine Avenue 3 1 N/A $415,000 Unknown 255 days
Average: 4.1 2.7 2,294 $746,209 $325 60 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 58
Viewing 1 - 50 of 58
Sold Properties
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 DOM Sold Date
1265 Pine Avenue 3 2 N/A $527,000 $547,000 Unknown 35 days 1/19/22
352 Arcadia Drive 4 2 N/A $499,000 $555,000 Unknown 21 days 1/19/22
20 Barnard Street 3 3 N/A $499,000 $515,000 Unknown 11 days 1/11/22
470 Keith Lane 4 2 1,600 $564,500 $555,000 $346 72 days 1/10/22
804 Pine Avenue 3 2 N/A $579,000 $601,000 Unknown 14 days 1/7/22
103 Doncaster Avenue 4 2 N/A $598,800 $598,800 Unknown 3 days 1/4/22
18 Larkspur Drive 4 3 N/A $1,075,000 $999,000 Unknown 50 days 12/30/21
325 Arcadia Drive 3 2 N/A $499,990 $510,000 Unknown 4 days 12/30/21
319 Myrtle Avenue 3 2 N/A $575,000 $560,000 Unknown 65 days 12/29/21
242 Sears Road 4 2 N/A $470,000 $450,000 Unknown 41 days 12/28/21
1244 Madison Avenue 4 2 N/A $549,900 $600,000 Unknown 30 days 12/22/21
81 Wavecrest Avenue 3 2 1,314 $489,999 $483,700 $368 13 days 12/21/21
1348 Monroe Avenue 4 3 N/A $649,990 $667,000 Unknown 25 days 12/20/21
76 Malts Avenue 4 2 N/A $450,000 $448,000 Unknown 19 days 12/20/21
39 Skipper Drive 5 4 3,888 $1,299,000 $1,287,000 $331 24 days 12/17/21
12 Udalia Road 2 1 1,073 $425,000 $448,500 $417 14 days 12/16/21
44 Gladstone Avenue 5 4 3,566 $689,000 $725,000 $203 14 days 12/16/21
150 Norma Avenue 3 2 N/A $475,000 $502,000 Unknown 15 days 12/16/21
428 Oak Neck Road 2 1 1,400 $299,000 $370,000 $264 27 days 12/15/21
1930 Adams Avenue 4 2 1,850 $499,999 $565,000 $305 47 days 12/15/21
57 Dubois Road 3 3 N/A $539,000 $548,500 Unknown 13 days 12/14/21
2 Carol Ann Court 4 3 4,392 $869,000 $839,999 $191 10 days 12/14/21
1850 Monroe Avenue 4 3 2,144 $639,999 $660,000 $307 13 days 12/10/21
824 Tanglewood Road 3 2 N/A $399,000 $450,000 Unknown 4 days 12/10/21
45 Sylvia Drive 3 2 N/A $459,000 $525,000 Unknown 14 days 12/8/21
19 Beatrice Avenue 4 2 1,954 $649,316 $660,000 $337 23 days 12/8/21
122 Arbour Street 5 2 2,016 $549,000 $570,000 $282 43 days 12/8/21
707 Peter Paul Drive 5 3 N/A $535,000 $515,000 Unknown 41 days 12/7/21
1255 Madison Avenue 4 2 1,912 $625,000 $675,000 $353 5 days 12/2/21
105 Haynes Avenue 5 3 N/A $659,999 $650,000 Unknown 104 days 12/2/21
35 Skookwams Court 4 3 N/A $799,999 $765,000 Unknown 16 days 12/1/21
56 Pace Drive 3 3 N/A $874,900 $840,000 Unknown 60 days 12/1/21
48 North Street 3 2 N/A $399,999 $430,000 Unknown 24 days 11/30/21
430 Everdell Avenue 4 3 N/A $649,999 $625,000 Unknown 25 days 11/22/21
825 Ocean Avenue 3 2 N/A $499,999 $518,000 Unknown 7 days 11/22/21
705 Hyman Avenue 4 2 N/A $599,000 $600,000 Unknown 49 days 11/22/21
15 Davison W Lane 5 5 5,000 $1,595,000 $1,425,000 $285 84 days 11/22/21
19 Viking Drive 5 4 3,774 $1,499,000 $1,330,000 $352 24 days 11/18/21
324 Oak Neck Road 3 2 1,800 $585,000 $565,000 $313 89 days 11/17/21
18 Ryan Street 4 2 1,320 $575,000 $565,000 $428 17 days 11/16/21
33 Parkwood Road 4 3 1,866 $721,000 $721,000 $386 25 days 11/16/21
104 Ward Street 4 3 2,352 $669,000 $669,000 $284 18 days 11/12/21
236 1st Street 6 3 N/A $525,000 $552,500 Unknown 35 days 11/12/21
6 True Harbour Way 5 3 N/A $999,000 $1,250,000 Unknown 9 days 11/12/21
34 Ward Street 4 2 N/A $449,000 $465,000 Unknown 6 days 11/10/21
531 Rockaway Street 3 1 1,213 $415,000 $420,000 $346 24 days 11/9/21
34 Morris Avenue 4 3 2,738 $638,500 $655,000 $239 32 days 11/5/21
13 Dubois Road 4 3 N/A $649,000 $635,000 Unknown 40 days 11/4/21
38 Morris Avenue 4 3 N/A $629,000 $649,000 Unknown 28 days 11/4/21
1318 Wilson Place 3 2 1,460 $429,000 $435,000 $297 6 days 11/3/21
Average: 3.7 2.3 2,173 $610,426 $617,692 $321 29 days
Viewing 1 - 50 of 70
Viewing 1 - 50 of 70


Display of MLS Data is usually deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate by the MLS. Buyers are responsible for verifying the accuracy of all information and should investigate the data themselves or retain appropriate professionals. Copyright 2022 OneKey All rights reserved.